Sunday, August 16, 2020

Liberte Du La Mort / The Mars Volta - Frances The Mute Tour (2005-2006) Bootleg Reviews


In early 2005, The Mars Volta started touring in support of their long awaited second album, Frances The Mute, on a long tour with multiple shows that varied in length, but usually longer than the two hour mark. A lot of recordings from these shows can be found, and as with many bootlegs, they vary in quality, making up for a considerably large archive of what is considered by a lot as a great time for Volta's live shows (I could get my hand on 16 of these shows to be precise). The setlist for most of these were very similar for the most part, but almost every show had unique aspects to itself. Making an individual entry for each one would feel disjointed, considering that a lot of these share many things in common, so I thought it would be more convenient to gather all of these on just one entry with different parts, constantly updating with each concert entry. All of this will be seen in chronological order, while looking at the specific characteristics of each show. 


The Mars Volta would release their sophomore record in early 2005, with the first editions of the record officially coming out in Japan on the 11th of February. Before this date arrived, The Mars Volta started the tour in promotion of this new record by kicking off their live shows in various placed of Tokyo. One of these concerts was given on the Liquid Room nightclub, where artists such as Jeff Mills had performed years before, where the band performed a set in February 8, three days before the album was available for purchase. What we have here is a concerts that follows in spirit to what was seem before in 2004. Long gigs, with a bunch of songs being performed and showcased for people to see, expanded with the improvisational skills of the band, and leading these with some notable stage presence carried by the chemistry of the members.

The performances are very tight, with most of these songs being showcased on a way that it was to be expected from them. They don't really hold a candle to what was seen months before during their shows on The Wiltern, but it was them warming up before starting with their longer sets. The sound quality here is a bit dirty to the ear, it is far from being annoying or terrible, but it leaves a lot to be desired. All the instruments and vocals can be perceived and appreciated on a nice way, and the crowd noise and the echo of the location don't affect too much. Overall, it is a very decent recording, going along well with a very decent show from the band.

But, just like with many Mars Volta shows during this era, there are some very noticeable qualities and moments to take away from this experience. Most notably, the fact that this was perhaps the first official live performance, and debut, of Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus. The version that can be found here is close to what would be seen on the album for the most part, finally showing where the  Facilis Descenus Averni middle section used on previous live performances of Drunkship of Lanterns (a track that was also performed here, with a different and more extensive instrumental jam, being a glimpse at what would eventually become the opener of most of these shows). Even the Con Safo outro is performed, with all the studio atmospheric segments appearing as well, without the inclusion of the field recordings, but being the only segment of the song being extended with jamming in order to transition to the next track. It wouldn't be much compared to future versions of the song, but it definitely stands out as being something new, intense, and special to witness on such a concert.

But besides that, there are some great moments from the set. The Concertina rendition that appears here, as short and simple as it feels compared to the rest of the tracks, has as much energy and as much emotion as the rest of the concert, being a very potent and engaging tune to listen to, showing the long road that they had crossed since they started in 2001. Cicatriz ESP is a great closer, and it still uses some segments of Cassandra Gemini during the improv segments, but this would change not so long after due to the inclusion of that big medley on the setlist. But even then, its far from being the best version of Cicatriz, and the same can be said for most of the songs, where the renditions are still great to listen to, but they had, would have done, much better with them. Still, the chemistry is on point, and there is no moment where the band fails at implementing the big coordination between all the parts, and the performances themselves from every member stand out as something highly energetic, surprisingly technical, and very engaging for an audience from beginning to end.

Overall, this is a good recording from the band, being a great archive of that would eventually come during that year. It shows glimpses at many things that would eventually happen with these concerts, where the band would expand them with new songs, and an even tighter improvisation. As a way to see the first renditions of what would become some of their best tracks to see on a live setting, this is very enjoyable. The sound quality could be much better, but it is good enough to appreciate all that this set had to offer (there is even footage of this show available online). A good introduction to kick off this era of the band, being really enjoyable overall.

Sound Quality: 7/10

Overall Rating: 7/10

Favorite Track: Concertina / Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus

Ancienne Belgique, Brussels, Belgium 22-02-2005

The Frances The Mute tour had a very nice start with the band's performances in Tokyo due to the promotion of the Japanese release of the album during early February. Those shows marked the beginning of a lot of things for this era of the band's career. They would continue with the long gigs that they had started to try some months before, with a number of songs being performed and expanded with improvisation. The jam segments that belonged to Frances The Mute would be replaced with normal improvs lead by the band's coordination, and the new songs would slowly be implemented on the set (with Cygnus....Vismund Cygnus being the first of these to be performed on full), but not being expanded as much as some of their more well known tracks at the time. However, this would only be the stepping stone for what a lot of these shows would become, slowly introducing some new elements and having the gigs have much more to offer at the end of the day, having some of the most layered and loosened performances of their entire career.

After their show on February 8 in the Liquid Room, the band would take a very short break before coming back to the stage on Belgium due to the European release of their album taking place on the 21st of that same month. Just one day after, Volta would perform on Ancienne Belgique, and this show would be the one that implement some of the most notable aspects of their shows during this live era of the band. The main issue that this recording has is the fact that the sound quality could be much better. The crowd noise sometimes overlaps some segments of the songs, and others the instruments themselves overshadow themselves. It is a very rough recording to get used to, and while it is not necessarily terrible, it could use a lot of work in order for the songs to be appreciated on a better way, since the overall experience gets dragged down due to this odd quality with the sound, something that they truly deserve.

This is such a shame, because this recording, this particular performance from the band, is a considerable improvement on what was seen on Tokyo. Adrian Terrazas would officially join the main lineup of the band as an important member in percussion duties with flute, saxophone, and other instruments; and his presence can be greatly felt all throughout this concert. His incorporation, aiding Marcel with percussion on the normal tracks and then having his important segments on Frances The Mute's tracks, would make the whole music feel much more tighter, but the rest of the members do not hold back whatsoever. Every member is pushing themselves to their absolute limits, offering some very intense, precise, and very energetic performances; something that would only continue to increase with the following concerts. Jon easily provides some of the best drumming of his entire career, Ikey's keyboards have much more relevance in every song, being noticeable for complementing the rest of the instruments, Juan's bass is fast and precise, getting used to Omar's frantic and dynamic guitar (where the use of pedals increases to a whole different level), and Cedric's vocal range is incredibly polished, providing segments where his voice bleeds out and his shift in tone is very drastic and precise.

The band would start embracing all those different elements on a concert that had a very similar structure to the long concerts that were presented in 2004. The versions of Take The Veil, Drunkship of Lanterns, and Roulette Dares are all great, staying on the norm of what was to be expected from them at that point, with each of them being expanded in their own particular way with the jam segments (and having the Frances The Mute bits completely removed from them). Concertina, like always, stands out as one of the highlights of the set, a very short track, but incredibly potent on its energy and execution from all the members, definitely serving as a way to show how much they had improved since their early performances, proving that they didn't need drugs in order to display a psychedelic and intense onstage presence. The Widow is presented here, officially debuting live (it had been shown before as an acoustic piece on The Wiltern) as a new track of the new album, being very potent on the sound but being affected by the sound quality. It eventually leads into the rendition of Cygnus found here, being very similar to the one given on Tokyo, but improved with Adrian's percussion.

However, the main event here is the final track, the encore section that would be introduced right after Concertina. Cedric interacts with the audience on a charismatic way, just like every time, and another new song from their new album would be played in full: Cassandra Gemini, with this being its first live appearance on the group's career. This would be the song to replace the appearance of the long renditions of Cicatriz ESP on these concerts (considering that the jam segments on these used elements from Cassandra it would only be natural to think of it as the case), being performed on its entirety as the closer for every set. Without a doubt, this is the concert's highlight, an amazing way to end a concert, with almost thirty six minutes where the band showcases everything that they are capable of, starting of as an unexpected explosion of sound that catches the audience, and the listener, off guard. It is not perfect, but most of the segments appear here, and there are a lot of points that definitely stand above the rest, with every member providing their own piece of the puzzle. Adrian's flute and saxophone parts are incredible, Marcel's small percussion details, with some of Omar's most dense and impressive guitar playing, Jon's ability to never stop with his instrument, Ikey's atmospheric keyboards that complement the tone, Juan's ability to present a meticulous performance, and Cedric's outstanding vocals. It is all carried on a fantastic way, with them being able to jam and coordinate on an impressive manner, being able to shift in tone on a total resonance, from adrenaline filled segments to chaotic interludes that transition right into calm sections. It all flows on a very coherent and engaging way, and the fact that they are able to replicate and even improve some parts of the studio version simply goes to show their talent and incredible onstage presence. It is such a shame that the main issue with this is the sound quality, leading to some parts not being very clear on what exactly is going on. But still, it is the definitive highlight of the concert, a fantastic closer, a phenomenal track, and something that has to be heard in order to be fully appreciated by any fan of the band.

Overall, this recording is certainly something very special. The proper starting point of a tour that would be full of intense and engaging performances (some recordings of this concert can be found online). The De-Loused tracks here are great as always, but they would improve even more with each show. Definitely a step up from what was seen in Tokyo, and it is worth it just for the performance of Cassandra Gemini alone. The whole band is starting to display their full potential, and that can be felt with each track that is showcased here. If it wasn't for the sound quality, full of odd moments and a rough sound, this would definitely be a much more essential performance for any fan of the band. But still, what a fascinating and highly enjoyable set.

Sound Quality: 6/10

Overall Rating: 7.5/10

Favorite Track: Cassandra Gemini / Concertina


Paradiso Grote Zaal, Amsterdam, Netherlands 23.02.2005


2005 could be argued as one of the most notable years for The Mars Volta in general, regarding both their studio and live efforts. From early on that year, the band had already started to display their onstage abilities by performing relatively lengthy gigs where they showcased a collection of various songs from their catalog, while expanding them with improv or simply making those renditions be a presentation of their ability to replicate the studio elements onstage. This was all done with the band adding their unique energy to the mix, bringing their chemistry together to play their complex compositions on a very intense, coordinated, and precise way. Despite these long gigs being similar to what was seen on different points throughout 2004, they had already started changing their set list in order to present things that would be common during all that tour (most notably replacing the appearance of the long renditions of Cicatriz ESP with the complete version of Cassandra Gemini, which did not receive any expansion with the improv, rather having different elements from the studio version be changed in favor of bringing a different version of the track for every show).

Following the early days of the tour, not long after Frances The Mute received its European release, the band kept doing venues across different parts of Europe, and after performing on Belgium, the band moved to the Netherlands in order to keep promoting their new album the next night. The sound quality here is nice, certainly much cleaner compared to the night before, but the volume on all channels is very low. This is something that could easily be fixed, but increasing the decibels or trying to change the mix makes everything be filled with static (mostly having to do with the quality of the device that captured this audio). Not only is it about the overall volume, but that means that some things stay too in the background (sometimes getting affected by the echo created by the structure of the venue) or just aren't all that audible for some periods of time. It is not something particularly annoying while using speakers, in fact that is the best way to experience this recording, but using headphones really shows the main issues with this bootleg.

Besides that, the set and performance of the tracks is very similar to the one given the previous night, but some things do change. This time, an extended version of Drunkship of Lanterns is performed as an opener, something that would be quite common during this tour, becoming a sort of spiritual replacement of Cicatriz in the time it would manage to achieve during some of these concerts, being a very energetic and well carried track, with the way that it manages to go back to the main song being such an unexpected and lively moment. The Widow and Take The Veil have much more tighter performances, where all the members start feeling much more comfortable with the way the renditions end up coming out. This time around, Cygnus stands out as a very frantic, calculated, and impressive piece, where the energy and the potential of the band starts showing on a very fantastic way. Cedric's vocal performance is certainly something incredibly special, being on point with most of the notes for most of the time, something that would only keep on improving during the rest of the Frances tour. Roulette Dares and Concertina carry the same energy as always, and it all leads to Cassandra Gemini being a powerful closer.

Another thing to take into consideration is the fact that now the flow between tracks is never stopped. There is always some sort of pedal effect or small instrumental interlude connecting all the experience, making it much more immersive and tiring, but having a lot of things to offer in return. Cassandra makes its second official appearance, and even though it is shorter and not as energetic or well polished as the night before (being a relatively shorter rendition), it is still a fantastic track, and the highlight of the concert. Ikey's keyboards take the spotlight along side Juan's ominous bass lines and Jon's explosive drums, but all the band makes up for a very great version of this track, not showing some segments and instead replacing them with very intuitive jamming.

Overall, this concert is certainly something great. It is not as powerful of a performance as the one given one night prior, but it starts showing a band getting more comfortable with their abilities and their onstage presence (with everyone pushing themselves to provide some very precise and energetic performances with their respective instruments), but also marking other things that would be very common during that particular tour (such as the positioning of some tracks, the overall flow that is never stopped when transitioning from one song to the other, among many other things). The sound quality is the main issue this time around, something that would continue being common, as expected, with many of these bootlegs, dragging the overall experience down as a consequence. Still, it is a great show, just as expected from this period of the band.

Sound Quality: 7/10

Overall Rating: 7.5/10

Favorite Track: Cassandra Gemini / Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus





There are many different points across a band's career that can be marked as special, standing out for what they were doing at the time on their live shows, for the music that they were putting out, and sometimes for both of those reasons. One such thing happened with The Mars Volta across many different points of their career, such as some shows spread across different points in 2005 from their tour in promotion of Frances The Mute. Just like with many tours, and specially with a band with such a marked way of presenting long gigs that were heavy in atmosphere due to the amount of things that were going on onstage, the energy and performances of the band started getting fleshed out with every new concert, with every little change added in order to present a very flexible and unexpected set for each night of this tour. Just at the start of these dates, performed in Japan and then moving to Europe, matching the release of the album on those locations, the band had started to present and improve on things that would be common during the tour. 

The long sets were more common this time around, with the band starting to incorporate some of their new tracks into the sets, but these also marking the change of the way other songs were performed. The jam segments that took different elements from songs that would be revealed as part of Frances The Mute (those used in Take The Veil, Drunkship of Lanterns, and Cicatriz ESP) were replaced by more conventional and unheard improvisations that varied from presentation to presentation. The Widow, which already appeared as an acoustic track in concerts during 2004, was performed along side Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus, but there was also the surprising inclusion of the complete thirty minute version of Cassandra Gemini being used as a closer during all this tour (replacing Cicatriz ESP in being the longer track of the set). The band was also expanding their abilities to replicate studio elements on a live setting, but particularly creating a non-stop flow between all the tracks lead by pedal effects or small interludes that lead to the appearance of some of the bands most immersive and atmospheric concerts until that point on their career. This was all introduced during the early stretch of the European sets (where a lot of different problems, such as the sound quality of the recordings from those nights, as well as the band just starting to get comfortable in that touring setting during that year, made those bootlegs things that could have been much more, but still having their own highlights to take from), but there was one particular presentation that, according to many fans, marked the true beginning of this tour. 

This particular performance would take place on March 1st, coordinating with the official american release of the album, in Berlin, Germany, and here is where a lot of the elements that had been introduced until that point start being used on a much better way. The show was noticeable much longer, having around thirty more minutes where things where displayed on a much more loose way, than the ones that preceded it. The "no breaks taken" approach from previous shows was expanded even more here, making this more than two hours of an immersive and intense gig, with all the songs here being fleshed out in very interesting ways. The venue was one of the best, where not a lot of the echo noises or structure of the building interfered with the sound of the band. The crowd was much calmer than the ones that appeared before, and even after this point, being very respectable of what was going on, adding to a performance that had a considerably less amount of crowd noise, and with the group itself feeling much more comfortable playing on that setting (and even if better performances would come after, the audience and crowd noise were always elements to deal with in the quality of the bootlegs). This would all lead to fans considering this the show where the "European tour actually started". 

But even taking all of that into consideration, this is not a perfect recording. As with many of these, the main issue relies on the sound quality of the gig, being one of the more polished recordings from 2005, but still being a thing that many could take some time to get used to. The instrumentals are clean, and most of the elements used across the songs can be heard and appreciated on good quality, with the echo of the venue being something that doesn't affect the recording too much. The vocals, however, are a little unbalanced in the audio channels, most of the time being thrown into the left channel more than anything, but still being something that just takes time to get used to. There is some minor phasing, and it could certainly be something of a much better quality, but it is all nicely balanced overall (despite it having some rather abrupt changes in volume at the time). It doesn't affect the actual concert all too much, and it lets these great renditions be properly appreciated on a very nice way. In a few words, and to put it on a wider perspective, this is one of the bootleg that is used the most to show the state of the band during this period of their career. 

All the songs here have something to offer. The show starts with one of the longest renditions of Drunkship of Lanterns to be given until that point (being that these extended versions of the track would be the norm during most of the tour). Just with this opener the band is capable of showcasing the importance of every member on the track, with everyone playing an important role in order to bring a much more fleshed out version of the track. Many things could be pointed out as being the main factors of this, but the main thing is the fact that Adrian's saxophone playing, Marcel's percussion, and Ikey's subtle keyboard atmospheres and dynamic way of playing, are all things that are very important to these performances, with details that do a lot for these songs. Everyone plays a vital role in carrying the song forward, specially the improvisational segment. This is certainly one of the more special versions of Drunkship, with a lot of different elements, both created on the spot and even hinting at some things to come (like the fact that Cedric seems to use early lyrics that would be seen on Amputechture or some Omar riffs and pedal effects that would be later used on some of his solo projects, such as The Apocalypse Inside Of An Orange), that provide for a very dynamic, intense, and unpredictable jam. Juan's precise bass lines, Jon's explosive and dynamic drumming, Omar's engaging way of playing being expanded with his varied use of pedals, and Cedric's impressive range, with his voice being manipulated to create some echo at points, and some of his tones bleeding of passion on the performance. It all flows naturally, shifting between tones and moods, eventually seeming like it fades away just to return to the main song and end things on a very impressive way, kicking off the concert on an already outstanding way.

The Widow follows up as a sort of break from the frantic energy that was provided, a very sweet and passionate performance, where all the instruments come together once again to provide a very powerful rendition of the track, where all the details add to the overall experience (such as Ikey's background keyboards or Adrian's saxophone solo replacing Flea's trumpet). The renditions of Take The Veil, Cygnus, Roulette, and Concertina that come right after are some of the best to come out from this early period of the tour, with all the band giving their all to make up for some impressive performances that take the audience to many places, never dropping the pacing and the constant liveliness of their playing. Finally, Cassandra Gemini closes the experience on a fantastic way, this time implementing even more of the studio elements, such as the manipulated dialogue part right at the start of the track, in order to flesh out the track along side the diverse improvisation that is being provided by all the members. It certainly serves as a fantastic climax to the entire experience that had been presented until that point, with all the member pushing themselves to another level in order to coordinate between them and provide precise, intense, and highly layered segments that flow together on an engaging and fascinating way. Certainly something that has to be heard in order to be understood, being one of the best versions of the track that can be found live, but also closing one of the most recognized and loved concerts from this era of the band.

Without any sort of doubt, the sound quality and performances presented on this bootleg are a big improvement over what was seen until this point. Of course, a lot of things could be improved, and the band would still have plenty of impressive performances to offer across this tour in promotion of their second album, but despite all of that, the band displayed an ability to make all the elements they had used until that point something better implemented in their onstage performances. There is no doubt that they had a fantastic live presence, providing these heavy, intense, and non-stop displays of talent from their part, that did nothing more than engage the audience in all the musical bonanza that they had to offer. Thankfully, footage of this concert can be found online, available for anyone to understand why these jams and renditions are so special for many. It certainly could be much better with the right adjustments, but as it is, it is nothing short of jaw-dropping and enjoyable in so many levels.

Sound Quality: 8/10

Overall Rating: 8.5/10

Favorite Track: Cassandra Gemini / Drunkship of Lanterns


Following the European tour, and with their album finally released in the United States, the band kept performing in Germany, continuing with what many fans considered the "true start of the Frances The Mute tour". Two days later after their concert in Berlin, the band moved to Cologne, providing a concert that was very much similar to the one that was already given, but that presented a considerable amount of differences compared to what was seen before.

For starters, this particular recording has some of the weakest sound quality from any of these bootlegs seen so far. It is not too noticeable on speakers, but once headphones are plugged in, the sound between channels is very inconsistent. Abrupt changes in volume, in tone, sometimes right in the middle of the song, but it is too noticeable. The mix is something of a big issue as well, with the instrumentals feeling somewhat unbalanced and sometimes elements getting overshadowed between themselves (particularly the percussion elements, but surprisingly enough, the guitar was not the main elements that overshadowed the others this time around). The phasing is something that takes time to get used to, and the crows noise certainly interferes with a lot of the performances, with a lot of people talking, engaging in, what is to be assumed, as passionate conversations throughout most of the concert (most notably on the middle section of the show). The vocals are quite high up on the mix, but the overall sound of the venue and the crowd, along side the way that it was recorded, makes for something that can be heard, but that takes some time to get used to.

As for the performance itself, it is certainly very similar to what was seen before. A long rendition of Drunkship to open the concert, with the rest of the set being practically identical. These versions, however, still lack some of the details and overall energy that were given until that point, but it is still a good show to listen to in full. It might be because of the odd and unbalanced sound quality, or maybe because the band was just missing some of the elements that made the Berlin concert shine the way it did, but this is definitely a much weaker performance overall. It is still something impressive, and the band certainly knows how to engage an audience and complete the songs with different elements (even if some of those elements still feel overshadowed by other instruments, making it hard for them to be properly appreciated on full), but the different problems that come through the entire album drag the entire experience down. Despite it being a good show, it is still one of the weakest recordings until that point. If people want the exact set that was presented here executed on a much better way, they definitely have more things to take from with the Berlin recording from two nights before. Still, enjoyable and immersive, but it could have been much more.

Sound Quality: 6.5/10

Overall Rating: 7/10

Favorite Track: Cassandra Gemini


Right after The Mars Volta finished with the first stretch of their Frances The Mute tour in early 2005 that took place in Japan and different parts of Europe, the band moved to the United States in late April in order to continue with the promotion of their second album, something that was rather delayed, considering that the album had its american release on early March, but that was to be expected, knowing that the band would take a month long break after their last performance in England on March 16. In order to continue with the tour, the band would eventually return to the stage on April 22, starting the second stretch of their 2005 tour by performing at the RIMAC Arena in San Diego, California.

First of all, and something that its not mentioned often with these bootleg recordings, is the fact that fans are lucky to have access to such archives, since they help people understand and appreciate the constant evolution of the band, as well as many of their unique onstage qualities that made them a musical act that shouldn't be missed by any chance during that time. Just like with many of these recordings, there were multiple sources available in order to listen to the full concert. The sound quality on one of these recordings is very odd, with the band being thrown too much into the background, leading to some elements and instruments to be overshadowed by both the crowd noise and other instruments, as well as the quality of the tape in some songs being inconsistent due to the sudden apparition of distortion or abrupt shifts in volume. The second source however, the one that is often recommended to fans, has a much more consistent sound quality all throughout the tracks, with the major issue being that at some point in Cassandra the quality shifts very suddenly to a worse sound quality than the one present before, but also the fact that Drunkship of Lanterns is incomplete on this source, missing almost ten minutes of material, but still being something that doesn't really end up affecting the experience all that much. The vocals are on the background, the instrumentals are a little bit watery due to the positioning of the tape and the venue, which ends up creating a quality that takes some getting used to, but that doesn't really end up affecting that much. It could definitely be something much better that improves the recording instead of dragging it down due to the lacking aspects. But despite all that, this show still has very unique and impressive things to offer.

In order to kick things off, the band presented some noticeable changes on the set, re-arranging the positioning of some tracks and debuting some tracks on their live form, as well as having some unique changes on how the songs were being performed overall, with the band being much more aware of the importance of percussionists like Adrian and Marcel adding some old school style of backing instruments, creating tighter performances. The characteristic of the set being a non-stop flow between tracks seemed to be more and more polished with each new concert, here being something much more engaging and immersive on its execution. Drunkship of Lanterns starts things off in the same way as previous nights, being an extended version of the song that is well carried overall, with the improv segments shining in how well presented and executed they feel, with every member having an importance in the sound that comes out, shifting between different moods and tones, eventually dying down and then exploding back into the main song. Cedric continues having that charisma of his with his strong stance against violent crowds, encouraging them to dance and have a good time, before transitioning directly into Concertina (appearing early on instead of being used as a prelude for Cassandra), that has a very lively rendition. Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus, Roulette Dares, and Take The Veil follow right after, being nice performances of the tracks, being in line with what was already seen on previous gigs (but they are dragged down due to the sound quality that appears here), flowing between each other on a very nice way, and carrying the same energy that was to be expected from them. After all that, the definitive highlight of the bootleg stands out with the last three song stretch. The Widow is as passionate and impressive as ever, despite carrying a different mood and tone compared to the rest of intense and technical tracks.

The outro of the song is a little bit extended, but it transitions into the interlude to L'Via L'Viaquez, making that the first night that the song was officially performed live. This is definitely something that shines above many things presented so far on the set, being a very catchy and dynamic song where all the members are able to give their all onstage by shifting tone and having their important contributions to the song. Omar's guitar solos (very Frusciante inspired in how they are carried through, and his very dynamic and engaging use of pedal work), Juan's calm and precise bass (complementing Omar's guitar on a very balanced way), Jon's impressive drumming (definitely being some of the best of his entire career, specially with the small drum solo he is given), Ikey's keyboard/piano talent (more noticeable and impressive on the calm salsa driven segments, providing very suiting melodies), Marcel's narrow use of percussion (with his small contributions making up for tighter segments), Adrian's wonderful flute (showing the 70's progressive rock/jazz-fusion influence bleeding through, being a fascinating piece to add to the original song, making it something definitely special), and Cedric's wonderful vocals (that despite singing in Spanish are able to transcribe the studio elements on a live setting on a wonderful way, achieving some remarkable high notes and improvising on a very unique way with his times). It all makes up for an excellent track to be appreciated by both audiences and listeners. It all leads into the classic closer of this tour, Cassandra Gemini, being a nice rendition of the track, having the enhanced elements seen on L'Via bleeding through, making up for a great track to end a gig with (that is sadly dragged down by the sudden shift in sound quality seen at the middle of the song).

This San Diego performance is not perfect, and it could have been something better executed in some regards, but it still has a lot to offer. What can be seen here is an enjoyable concert, definitely a great way to start the second stretch of the tour, with a lot of different elements to admire. The set is as immersive, intense, and layered as ever, and the re-arrangement of the setlist makes up for a very dynamic and surprising experience that manages to balance all the elements that it has to its disposition. It is a shame that the sound quality can't be improved that much, since this has some fantastic renditions of tracks accompanied by impressive performances. It is something that definitely deserved better in that regard, but that ends up getting dragged down due to how unbalanced it can feel as a whole, even after multiple listens. But even with all those issues, this is still something incredibly enjoyable.

Sound Quality: 7/10

Overall Rating: 7/10

Favorite Track: L'Via L'Viaquez / Cassandra Gemini


The Mars Volta finished their month long break after finishing the first stretch of their tour in promotion of Frances The Mute in March, not long after the american release of the album had taken place, and then returned to their live performances in order to appear in different parts of the United States by late April. This new part of the tour was already starting to present some noticeable improvements compared to the previous gigs, even very early on with the San Diego performance, with some major differences being the live debut of L'Via L'Viaquez and much more polished, precise instrumental performances from all members of the band, with every single one of them having an important role in how the songs turned out in the final product (most notably an increase in the recognition that Marcel, Adrian, and Ikey deserved with their respective talents). This would only keep on improving even more with the following dates, leading to some of the more iconic and impressive concerts from the band. But this could be seen even not long after the RIMAC show, most particularly on the recording of April 29, a concert that took place on the Tabernacle in Atlanta, Georgia.

To put it on a very simple and straight forward way: this is a noticeable improvement over the recording and performance that could be found on the San Diego bootleg, and it is definitely a better way to experience what was being offered that night (despite the fact that these performances, and this new arrangement of the set in particular, would have much better renditions not long after). The important factor that makes this be the case is very simple: the sound quality is much better. It is not a perfect quality for a bootleg or a concert such as this, since many different issues appear across the entire recording, affecting the overall experience, and dragging it down as a whole. There were two cited sources from the person who recorded the show, and he managed to mix them together in order to achieve a more complete sound, but there are a lot of rough spots to be found here. The vocals are much more balanced before, but they are thrown a little bit too much to the background along side the instrumentals. It is not something that is all that noticeable on speakers, but on closer inspection it does require some time in order to get used to (but it also presents sudden shifts in volume in that regard, once again, most notably on the middle section of Cassandra).

After Cygnus, before transitioning to L'Via, these is a rather odd choice for a but, maybe trying to resemble the fade-out / fade-in that happens between the different sides of a vinyl, but it is completely unnecessary and it messes the pace of a non-stop concert on an evident way. The crowd noise is not annoying, but there are some segments where it is very much something distracting. As for the concert itself, some things are changed, creating a set that would be the norm for the following dates of the tour. The long rendition of Drunkship kicking things off, with Concertina following right after in all its noticeable energy. Take The Veil going into Cygnus while being some great renditions, and it all goes into the fantastic highlight of L'Via L'Viaquez. It all flows seamlessly, until getting to the final stretch of Roulette Dares, The Widow, and Cassandra Gemini, closing up the concert on a very impressive way. The energy carried from the San Diego performance bleeds through, and it is all improved, making it for a much better archive of those songs being played live during that time, as well with many different details that make the overall playing something much tighter and well crafted. This particular setlist would continue for a big portion of May, and it would bring some very impressive and recognized concerts from the band, so for this being a starting point in that regard makes this something fascinating to listen to.

In the end, the major issues rely on the sound quality. All those minor issues end up making for noticeable problems that could have been much better in order to improve the recording instead of dragging it down. But even then, this is an incredibly enjoyable collection of tracks showing a band that kept on improving on a live setting. It wouldn't be the best rendition of this arrangement of tracks, but it is still something recommended for fans to listen to, only asking if they can overlook those little details that mess with the performances in order to appreciate such a wonderful live concert.

Sound Quality: 7.5/10

Overall Rating: 8/10

Favorite Track: L'Via L'Viaquez / Cassandra Gemini


IMPORTANT NOTE: This is not the concert that has video footage available online and on forums, that would be the second night that the band performed at the Electric Factory during that tour.

Of course, this era of the band is incredibly divisive, between outsiders and people who really love the band, with others maybe even considering such a show to be something tiring, unnecessary, and "wanky"; but in the end it being something really special to witness even after so many years, to see what distinguished the band from many other acts at the time, with their own onstage presence and unique performances.

Following their tour in promotion of Frances The Mute, The Mars Volta had already finished their first few gigs at the end of April in order to warm up for their future American concerts. They had already started to show a lot of promise for what would be this part of the journey, adding new elements to their European counterparts, which already provided for some impressive performances, like the live debut of L'Via L'Viaquez and its implementation as a common part of the sets from that point forward and the fact that they rearranged their gigs in order to keep a different and unique feeling for every different night. All the members in the band kept giving their all in order to provide for great performances, showing their evolution from what was seen before on the De-Loused tour, carrying the energy into extensive renditions of some tracks, as well as showing that their new songs had some incredible potential in that setting. And that could be seen night after night, even without a very big time gap between concerts. Such is the thing with the thing that happened after their concert in Atlanta, Georgia, with the band moving to perform at the Electric Factory in Philadelphia, starting their first of two concerts that would be given there, in May 1st.

If there is one thing that can't be denied by most fans it's the fact that Volta's run during those years provided some of the most engaging, immersive, and fascinating performances from the band's career. However, and one thing that happens with many other musical acts as well, finding a good quality recording of these concerts is certainly an achievement in it of itself. It is something that keeps being the norm with this tour. The performances are really impressive, with a lot of things to take from regardless of the concert that is being listened to, but the thing that drags most of these down to an unbelievable degree is the really inconsistent sound quality, with some times it being much more bearable than the others. Many different facts can contribute to these recordings ending up the way they did, from crowd noise, the echo created by the venue, to the positioning of the person who recorded the show, it all varies a lot depending on the gig itself. For this particular concert, three sound sources can be found, each one presenting different issues that the tapers encountered with, creating different end results. Even if trying to mix the different tapes into one balanced recording, these issues make that possibility something hard to achieve, which is why it is better to look at these individually.

Source 3: Sony Net MD Walkman MZ-505 Type-R

The third source is easily the weakest one of the group. Starting out on a very evident way, indicative of what would come, with the version of A Fistful of Dollars being very far in the background (starting on a very low volume while the tapper is setting all up), even at high volume, with the following mini jam before Drunkship giving an idea of how far the taper was from the stage, with the sound quality letting most of the instruments be heard, but with some of them clearly overshadowing the others. Many issues come to be during the recording, like about a one minute cut-out during Drunkship due to the mic input falling out, the tape flipping and breaking up the pacing aft the end of Cygnus transitioning into L'Via, or the convoluted audio that can be perceived from Take The Veil to Roulette Dares. It is all made worse with the low volume in the final mix, maybe something to do with the way it was converted into this media, something that even in full volume keeps making a lot of the elements become almost unnoticeable (and even with using speakers only, it doesn't really do all that much for saving this sound quality). Definitely something that could have been much more, but the gear, positioning, and issues during the recording drag the reliability of this source down. It is something that does end up being annoying, even after a few listens, being something odd to get used to.

Sound Quality: 5.5/10

Source 2: Core Sound Binaurals > Core Sound Battery Box (filter on) > Nomad Jukebox 3

This second source is an improvement over what was seen before, but the result is not that much better overall. The taper used a filtered device, then transferred and adapted into different sources until getting to the final product available for download, but the end result was something that was still odd in the balance of the instruments and the volume of the entire concert. There isn't crowd noise or echo, as well as any sort of abrupt cut going on at given moments, affecting this recording, but the elements seem to overshadow each other at times. It is something much more tolerable than the third source, but it still takes a lot of time to get used to, and it definitely doesn't do justice to what is going on in the performances.

Sound Quality: 6.5/10

Source 1: Sony Mic > D100

The first source is, without a doubt, the best one. It is much more cleaner, and doesn't have any sort of odd filter or rare sound qualities to be found, making it the best recording to get in order to try and appreciate what this show had to offer. However, this is not without its fare share of problems, with some elements of the band feeling too much in the background, while others come in different parts and volumes in the mix (just listening to how clear the audience sounds at times by clapping or random conversations going on gives an idea that this could have picked up the band with a much better sound quality if the taper had a better position in the end). The volume of the channels changes at times, flowing from one to the other at what seems to be rather unexpected and random times, with the reason why not being so clear in the end. This is also the recording where the crowd noise is the most audible, with the echo of the venue affecting some of the songs as well, but compared to the other two this is much more bearable and easier to adapt to. It is not perfect, but a lot of different factors were the ones affecting this source, and even if fans can be glad to have this in order to get impressed with what the band had to offer, it keeps on dragging down the potential of what is one of the most impressive shows from that particular tour.

Sound Quality: 7.5/10

Even then, with all the different sound qualities found on the many recordings of this concert, it is not enough to make something like this justice. The show that was performed that night is one of the longest to be found on this tour, a two hour and a half behemoth that portrayed all the things that made the band unique on a very impressive way. The band went out of their way to flesh out their jamming on a very fascinating way, with the use of their many influences and even getting to use elements from other songs on their catalog. The non-stop feeling that is conveyed throughout this entire concert is pulled off on a much more balanced way with the transitions between songs, and the songs themselves have some very strong renditions to be found here. Everyone has their role, and the percussion use is implemented even more, but the sound quality barely lets all of that to be appreciated in the end result, which is nothing less of a shame.

The concert starts off with one of the longest renditions of Drunkship to be found on this tour, with its execution rivaling that one of Berlin, being a thirty+ minute musical bonanza that shows how special the chemistry between the members was during that era. All the elements from previous extended versions of this track are brought back and expanded with new ones, and every single member has their important role in the end result, carrying everything forward with their coordination, talent, and onstage dominance. Everything flows seamlessly, eventually fading the jam parts in order to unexpectedly return to the main track, making everything feel energetic and well carried, despite the length that the track ends us getting. Concertina follows right after as a break of the immersive and dense opener, with Cedric's vocals being as tight in the performance as ever, and minor elements like Adrian's saxophone coordination with Omar's guitar, or Jon's bombastic drumming being much more energetic than earlier performances of the song, adding to a much more polished rendition of a classic song from their early catalog. Take The Veil has one of its longest versions present here, with the band starting to implement even more elements into the jam without losing the initial pace, getting an intense, loose, and lively performance that is instantly contrasted with the calm and tense transition into Cygnus.

The way Cygnus starts is unexpected, a musical explosion that does justice to the studio version by being a very energetic and precise rendition, managing to replicate the various studio elements on a live setting, but also expanding them in order to offer more with the performance, but it also goes to show how much the band had changed things up since their previous performances. The debut of the tracks from Frances The Mute meant that the jamming had to change for many tracks, but the band still managed to carry everything forward on a very impressive way in that regard, and it all felt natural and without any sort of extra elements being forced in whatsoever. The way that the band was able to offer dynamic sets every night was the thing that made them earn the reputation that they got during that point o their career, and it definitely shows, regardless of the sound quality. Cygnus ends on a calm way, with Juan's Con Safo bassline being looped over and over, with Cedric improvising some lyrics, eventually stepping down and giving way to Omar's guitar to start introducing, on an almost subtle way, the main guitar line of L'Via, while the atmospheric effect created by the pedal and the sound manipulation gives the members some time to rest in order to get prepared for the next track, with the proper studio transition to L'Via taking over and kicking off one of the definitive highlights of the entire show.

The way L'Via is carried forward, with the guitar solos, the atmospheric salsa influenced segments, and the improvised outro, is genuinely some of the best things to come out of this entire tour. Every single night this song manages to become something truly special, regardless of the main song (which is a masterpiece in it of itself), with the loose outro showing the potential of every single member from the band (but particularly letting space for Adrian's percussion abilities and Ikey's talent on the keyboard to shine, with Omar and Cedric following right after). It all fades out slowly, leaving Cedric's voice to keep stating the iconic line from the song, until everything dies down transitioning into Roulette Dares. The rendition of the actual song is as energetic and iconic as ever, but the version that can be found here is one of the longest ones from the song, particularly because the end segment is extended with the atmospheric jamming calming things down, but also showing the range of tones that the band is able to take at any given moment, eventually dying down in order to let a great version of The Widow take the lead. This is one of the more studio oriented versions of the track to be found on this tour, with the only thing dragging it down being the underwhelming sound quality found throughout all the different sources of this show. The small jam after The Widow changes the tone suddenly, keeping things tense and misleading in order to get to the intense and long closer in the form of Cassandra Gemini. As with every single show of this tour, this is a track that must be listened to in order for it to be fully understood. This is a very particular rendition of the song however, since it hints at many other tracks throughout the duration of the jamming, going from different songs from the band's many influences, to hints at the main riff of Frances The Mute, and even vocal melodies from Eunuch Provocateur. Definitely a highlight of the entire set, a great way to end a concert, and a statement of the band embracing their particular style and way of dominating the stage with their unique presence.

If the sound quality from any of the sources was much cleaner and balanced in the mix (with the instrumentals being polished enough to be appreciated and the different issues with the channels being fixed), this would be, without any sort of doubt, one essential recording from this period of the band. However, the lacking sound quality drags the entire experience down, and doesn't let some elements be fully appreciated in the end result, which truly is a shame. But still, I would personally recommend any fan of Frances The Mute and De-Loused to check out this concert. A long show that shows the huge potential of the band at the time, being very intense, energetic, and immersive; managing to be really enjoyable in the end, despite all the off putting qualities that the different sources might present.

Overall Rating: 7.5/10

Favorite Track: L'Via L'Viaquez / Cassandra Gemini



https://youtu.be/A7OocJUWZuU

Source 1:

Sound Quality:

DVD Source:

Sound Quality: 8/10

Overall Rating: 7.5/10

Favorite Track: L'Via L'Viaquez / Cassandra Gemini


Used in Scabdates

https://youtu.be/1T1sRQqMFWM

Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Used in Scabdates

Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:


Sound Quality:

Overall Rating:

Favorite Track:

Saturday, August 15, 2020

And Now We Wait For The Fate Of The Others / The Mars Volta - A Missing Chromosome (2005) Bootleg Review


The Mars Volta's career was certainly on a very good point in 2005. They had gone through a multitude of different things ever since they started playing live in 2001. Members leaving the band due to personal issues, leaving them on a rough spot when recording their debut album (where they were being limited by Rick Rubin's decisions as a producer), just to then have their beloved friend and band member die due to a heroin overdose, shaking the energy and attitude of most of the members. This lead to the band be somewhat unmotivated for some time, but with the tours in late 2003 and the specially great year that was 2004 for their live performances, they were back on track, and the statement that they were as strong as ever came in the form of their second album Frances The Mute, accompanied by big shows in promotion of the album. All of this left fans wondering what would come next in the band's career, but their music up to that point left a lot of things to be noticed in the form of b-sides and some unreleased tracks.

During some point in 2005, and on the band's fan forums, someone posted the link to a supposed EP released by the band and their label meant to be sent to different radio stations as promo material, containing a compilation of different tracks, outtakes, and B-sides. Truth is, this was nothing more than a fan project being shared under this false premise in order to gather some kind of attention. It was never released physically, and it was only spread via torrents, with someone eventually added a front cover that only kept the rumor about it being something official. However, under the name A Missing Chromosome, this release turned out to be a curiously great compilation that offered a good look at some overlooked tracks on the band's catalog, with it being a very nice way to present these in order to get fans to appreciate them. These were also extracted from a multitude of places across the group's career, with them being arranged on a chronological order, from 2002 until 2005, and it being a good look at how the band changed over the years, getting to the point where they were in 2005, making this a rather essential release for anyone that wanted to get into Volta's music.

Tracks 1-3 (Tremulant EP)

As it was mentioned by other fans, the fact that the entirety of the Tremulant EP is included here makes the original release obsolete. What can be seen here is the first official release coming from the band, with Eva Gardner on bass and Jeremy Ward on sound manipulation (only thing older than these would be the Roulette Dares and Cicatrix demos with Blake Fleming on drums). The three songs that are included show the bridge between the straight forward song structures that Omar and Cedric were used to in At-The Drive In and the loose but precise experimentation that The Mars Volta would embrace, adapting things from De Facto into the way they wrote and performed music. The production was in charge of Alex Newport (who had produced In/Casino/Out and Vaya before) and Omar, but they were limited in that regard, making some of the versions found here feel limited by the budget and the resources that the band could get their hands to at the time. 

However, some classic tracks from the early period of the band are found here, but their final state is certainly something that could benefit from a different production and vocal performance. The band wanted to capture the live feeling from their energetic and frantic shows (they would eventually achieve that later down the line), but what could be found here were versions that wouldn't come close to these live performances, while still having a lot to offer due to them being the first official look at the potential of this new project. Cut That City presents the atmospheric buildups that lead into the main song, with some great instrumentals and a manipulated and somewhat flat vocal performance, with some sound manipulation added in. Concertina definitely feels like the song that had the most balance between all these elements. Despite the same unbalanced vocal performances, the instrumentals are clean, and Cedric starts showing more attention and dedication with his vocal range, making this for a great track that has a lot to offer within its relatively short length. Eunuch Provocateur then shows the direction that the band would eventually head into, with the long tracks that present a relatively uncommon song structure, with some great instrumental performances, showing the big potential from the band's compositions on every front (with Jon's bombastic drums, Eva's precise and subtle bass, Ikey's complementary keyboards, and Omar's dynamic guitar). The watery vocals feel a little off, but they still manage to work with the song, but also presenting an odd three minute atmospheric outro that started showing glimpses at the experimental segments on their future projects.

The band would definitely take a big leap in production, even getting to re-record Concertina and Eunuch during the De-Loused Summer Sessions, improving them on many ways despite them simply being rough demos, but until that point it showed the potential of the band in studio, complemented with the incredible live shows that demonstrated the use of all the elements on a great way, showing a promising future for the band (something that would change with Eva Gardner leaving the band not long after the start of the Tremulant tour).


After that point, the band went into recording sessions with Rick Rubin for their debut album. These sessions were known as the Summer Sessions (where Flea was used as a bassist due to the fact that the band was still searching for a replacement of Eva), and in late 2002, rough demos and mixes from the sessions would leak online. Among those many tracks was the rough mix of what would become the unreleased A Plague Among Your Hissing (from which the title of this release was extracted from). Even on its rough state, the track is a big improvement production wise to the songs on their first EP. The song itself feels like an improvement of the songs from the first half of Tremulant, being a relatively short composition that aims to be straight forward with what it wants to present. But the performances here are more varied, having different segments and shifts in tone, with a great production in the vocals, where the effects added make them much more varied and functional, and it carrying an energy reminiscent of their live shows, but being expanded with the different production choices across the track (having a distinct "raw polished" result). It is not quite certain why this, and other songs, were removed from the final album (perhaps being another Rubin choice), but it showed that the direction where the band was heading was an improvement on what they had. Intense, captivating, and very dynamic, certainly a great track that any fan should listen to. 


Only one of the, rumored as, outtakes from the Summer Sessions would have an official release: Ambuletz, which was included with the special editions of De-Loused. This is a heavily atmospheric and dream like track, which had more in common with what would be seen on Omar's first solo album more than anything, but also showing things that would be expanded on Frances The Mute. It is a very haunting and layered track, with a lot of things going on, like the modulated drums (having an explosive and chaotic part that introduces one of Jon's most mesmerizing solos), the cryptic and watery vocals, the dreamy guitar layers, and the subtle bass. Mysterious in tone, with a lot of hidden messages and a very surreal and psychedelic performance from everyone. This track, or at least the vocal tones and even drum patterns, from it would be implemented on live jams, but as a whole this is an excellent oddity showing the band's more experimental side. It all makes up for one of the hidden gems in the Volta's catalog. A seven minute track that takes time to get into, but that offers a lot of things in return.


But talking about experimental, one of the band's most odd and particular tracks is found in the form of The Bible And The Breathalyzer. A spoken word driven track, presenting one of Cedric's most intriguing and surreal written pieces every, having a lot to analyze and dissect on its very own. The music matches that tone, but the vocals are the main focus (these adapting to the musical tone with the manipulation and the watery tone), some free improvisation from every instrument, even some percussion, and atmospheric distortion to surround the entire experience. Without a doubt, this is one of the band's most odd and experimental tracks, becoming more of an acquired taste than anything, presenting a chaotic and slow build up accompanied by Cedric's calm voice, until getting to an abrupt end, but still not feeling like an essential track, more like a nice novelty that went along well with this specific single. Something that has its own charm, and that certainly stands out on the band's catalog.


The original title of the band's second album was supposed to be Sarcophagus, but since one of the songs (one that the band considered crucial in order to decipher the concept behind the story told on the record) was removed, they decided to tie it all together by naming the album with the title of the missing piece. However, this song was not discarded from their catalog at all. It was released twice officially in single form, it was still played on live shows (something that was not usual for their "B-Sides", so its attachment to the main release was certainly strong), and its lyrics being included on the official CD version. Both official releases of the song came out the same day as the vinyl release of the album, and they were both attached to a different version of The Widow (with it being released as the B-Side of The Widow's Single). But one of these was released as a main single attached to the triple vinyl edition of the album, being more proof that these two were certainly related without any doubt (sharing part of the artwork already seen on the CD booklet, and coming with a sound manipulated live version of The Widow).

Frances The Mute is, in many ways, a microcosm of what the entire album would be. A build up, very reminiscent for this compilation to the one of Cut That City as if it was going full circle, building up the tone before transitioning into the main part of the track. This time the long songs were separated in different segments, almost as if they were strict movements, each one of them having distinct feeling to them, but still holding on together on a great was as just one big song being dynamic with it's tone, and also presenting atmospheric soundscapes that took its time to build up tension or set up a certain mood before transitioning to the next song. The lyrics (now telling a much more condensed and straight forward story) were tied together with the vocal performance as another instrument that was used to have coordination with the music, and the final product can definitely be considered one of their most polished songs to date due to the production handled by Omar himself, finally managing to capture the perfect balance between the live energy from the band and the very specific and clear studio effects. It was a statement of all that the band represented at the time, all their journey to get until that point, with the result being an album that presented their creative, conceptual, and instrumental peak; and all of that can be found on this essential track that any fan should check out.

++

A Missing Chromosome may just be a fan compilation elaborated with a false backstory behind it, but what it presents serves as a collection of tracks that show the journey that the band had gone through to get until that point. Be it some of their more well known tracks at the time, impressive  B-Sides, or simply some of their best and overlooked songs, all the tracks here have something to offer and are enjoyable at the very least, but overall it is definitely a fantastic release. Something essential for any fan of the band, with a lot of things to offer in return. Very enjoyable and worthwhile. 

Overall Rating: 9/10

Favorite Track: Ambuletz / Frances The Mute / Concertina 

Sunday, August 9, 2020

I'll Never Sleep Alone / The Mars Volta - Frances The Mute (2005) Album Review / Analysis / Explained


Overall Rating: 10+

//This is a review/analysis that is separated in four distinct parts. The first one being the introduction to the whole thing, focusing more in the context, the second focusing on the music, the third one explaining the concept that the lyrics present, and the fourth one being a conclusion, but also a much more condensed review of the album//

Talons Scratch My Suite

The rupture of the iconic post-hardcore group At The Drive-In seemed to still be a burden and an annoyance to Omar and Cedric, even four years after it happened. With news of the band splitting into two parts, with The Mars Volta and Sparta, the fans seemed to look for the same type of energy and style of music coming from both directions. Sparta was the one closest to the style that most fans wanted, being an alternative rock/post-hardcore project, but it wasn't the same in the sense that a lot of key factors were still missing, having some minor success. Omar and Cedric on the other hand, had derailed their music towards a more experimental and unique place with the creation of The Mars Volta. Both their EP and debut album had pushed through a lot of difficulties and managed to find a surprising success with the public. The music was complex, layered, cryptic in meaning, energetic, but still accessible to those who gave in to the experience and decided to sit all the way through, starting off one of the most unique, varied, and dynamic projects of the 2000's. However, fans and journalist still wanted to know the reason of their change in attitude or motivation that lead to their beloved band to end. But every time that they were asked that, Omar and Cedric always gave a similar answer: At The Drive-In simply changed directions

The public seemed to be demanding what they wanted to see from them, Omar and Cedric going wild onstage just for the sake of it, instead of waiting for something new. Both of them were simply tired of that energy, of the music, and they were seeking to create something new. They didn't like the fact that they needed to have band meetings in order to get permission to improvise was thought as ridiculous. In the end it was all about wanting to do what came naturally, improving and changing the formula whenever they felt like doing so, everything lead by sudden motivation and instinct, without the need to consult with anyone. The thrill and excitement of not knowing what would come next at every turn, with one author/director leading in studio, but eventually becoming a collective where anyone was able to take the lead on a live setting. In many ways, they seemed to be fulfilling that desire ever since the early days of The Mars Volta.

Their live shows carried a completely different energy compared to their previous major project, but still being intense, energetic, and carrying a lot of different layers, with every member having an important part in order to carry these new style of songs forward. As what happened with ATDI, they wanted to replicate that live tone on their studio records. And even though they had the power to get loose this time around, they were still troubled by different factors. Tremulant was dealing with limited production values, and De-Loused was limited due to Rick Rubin's decisions regarding the vision that the band had (which was something even longer and more experimental, with different values to the final mixing, but all of this was considered as appropriate for an audience by Rubin, cutting out a lot of the things that eh thought were extra). And even though both projects ended up being something fantastic (with De-Loused coming out as one of the most diverse and unique projects to ever come out, certainly a completely powerful debut album for any band), the artists did not seem satisfied with the final product. However, their debut had been successful, which gave the band a lot more liberties, and they were determined to make their sophomore album the way they wanted to.

Finally, they were able to be completely free with what they wanted to do in studio since their experimental days in ATDI. The direction of the new album was being led by the band doing whatever they wanted to do, looking to differentiate themselves from what they thought a big portion of artists were doing: doing what the public wanted them to do. They were called as to have "sold out" to a major label, but they knew what they were getting into by signing with universal. It wasn't about selling out, it was more about being aware that they could write their own contracts and establish things clearly in order to have their freedom. No producers to control or manipulate their vision, with Omar himself taking it upon recording and production duties in order to get things the way he wanted them to come out. Material for this follow up, both musical and conceptual, had been in preparation even when De-Loused was being recorded. Recording started in 2004, lasting a total of ten months, and their second album, taking the name of Frances The Mute, finally came out in early 2005.

Frances The Mute was much more daring and loose than their previous material was. They took all the elements from De-Loused and expanded them to reach a completely new level musically and conceptually (due to the fact that it was the band's second concept album). Every member was exploited and fleshed out to a completely new degree with their respective parts, creating a new branch of their sound that was not seen before. It was still The Mars Volta, but it was much more challenging to the listener, carrying a lot more layers and details that managed to be crafted on a way that nothing felt out of place. Experimental with its flow, with its compositions, with the story that was being told. The sound of the record replicated that frantic and intense, non-stop, live sensation, but still keeping the polished production and mixing, with a lot of surprising features to complete the sound and vision of Omar, done in memory of their beloved friend but also as a way to show that they were a band that was interested in pushing forward with their vision, doing whatever they wanted onstage as well as in their studio efforts.

Everything had a reason to be, and, as a whole project, it was not as accessible as De-Loused was. Those decisions were the things that separated those who had the patience to sit through what they had to offer and those who saw everything as "instrumental wankery". Despite all that, Frances The Mute still came out as a full experience available for anyone to try out. It had a lot to unpack between all those layers, and just like before, lyrics and music were different beasts (but this time around they complemented each other on a much better way), and each one impresses even more upon closer inspection. 

The Ocean Floor Is Hidden From Your Viewing Lens: The Music

Frances The Mute signified fleshing out the formula and the vision that The Mars Volta had presented with their previous material. A lengthier album, with long songs, a more polished way of presenting a concept, more features that helped in presenting the arrangements and compositions on a much better way, more atmospheric soundscapes that helped to keep a consistent and non-stop flow from one song to the other; it all served a purpose, with the production and recording being controlled by Omar himself, therefore not having any of his original vision affected by anyone else. Everything that made De-loused unique was expanded in such incredible ways. It was no longer just about replicating or improving a formula or capturing a live feeling, it was about adding more elements to it, pushing all the members to their limit onstage as well as in the recording studio.

All of this might end up coming out either terrible or great depending on the perspective of the listener, but that was the main intention. It was them doing what they felt like doing, without feeling the need of crafting a masterpiece, it was just doing things their way, expressing themselves freely with their music by blending all their inspirations into a thing that was their own, with them satisfied with the final result. Anyone was welcomed to experience what they had to offer, just asking for patience in order to witness the surreal and wonderful sounds that they had constructed.

But all of that did not come to be all of a sudden. The concept for the story of the album, as well as some musical drafts, are said to be from very early on in the band (even with members admitting that Blake Fleming was responsible for setting some of the rhythms on songs in Frances), but it was slowly polished on a more confident way with the passing of time. The music was being written and refined even with Omar touring with the band during the promotion of their debut album, trying out bits and pieces live during the jam segments in some songs (such as pieces of Facilis Descenus Averni on Drunkship of lanters, Con Safo in Take The Veil, or bits from Plant A Nail In The Navel Stream and Faminepulse on the long versions of Cicatriz ESP), or straight up debuting some full new compositions in the form of acoustic pieces (like what happened with The Widow), expanding those concepts slowly with each new set, leading to how they would end up being presented on the sophomore album. 

The recording process was very unique for them, and it would be the beginning of their usual routine for every album after that point. Their intention going to studio was a lot different with At The Drive-In, with Cedric thinking of it as a failed attempt at democracy, having all songwriting credited to the band as a whole, compromising the integrity of the art-form by not recognizing the true author, leading to tension and regret later down the line. With The Mars Volta this was much more simple and straight forward: Omar leads, Omar writes all stuff, bringing the skeleton in guitar to Jon in order for him to dissect it and build it up from that point, with all the members adding their parts individually until the final product was done. However, after Omar presented to them his vision, the rest of the work and talent depended on the members themselves, personalizing each segment in their own way, carrying their own energy and creativity while keeping the established backbone. It all became a collective effort that specially showed on a live setting, where anyone is able to take the lead with the instrumental jams and see if the rest can follow along. It was good chemistry more than anything, and that is what held the band together on that iconic lineup.

Their influences would also become a very important part in how they created that unique sound that only belonged to them. Each member had different musical taste, from Cedric liking Bjork and Throbbing Gristle, Jon being into black metal and classic bands like ZZ Top, Ikey having a big appreciation for pop music, Juan being into different styles of music, or Omar having that big passion for salsa. What was seen on the last album still had a strong presence, with different bands like Genesis, King Crimson, Barrett era Pink Floyd, Faust, Miles Davis or Can (specially this one, considering that Damo Susuki would come to work with Omar for a solo project), but the stronger presence of all the rest of elements lead to a tighter identity, grabbing from a lot of places and creating a particular sound (and even though they are cataloged as Progressive/Experimental Rock, their sound was very dynamic between the genres and moods that it touched, leading to a very unique style of music that doesn't really know a time or a place). But even then, it was that difference in musical and media taste that made things interesting for the members, because everyone had their own style of playing, but they still managed to go well with each other. The use of different arrangements and guests expanded this sound and polished it even further, with the end product being a varied, but still recognizable, musical concept.

Frances The Mute was recorded with the Miles Davis style of recording in order to get the best out of all the musicians that participated on the record. Since Omar was taking charge of production, everyone played their parts individually in front of him, without contacting the rest of the band or knowing what the rest of the instrumentals would sound like, only using a metronome to keep rhythm, playing things slowly at first in order to get the members to memorize their parts, with the tone or motivation being something that were not explained (similar to how David Lynch makes the actors perform on a very specific scene, without giving context and asking them to perform specific actions), in order to get every member to interpret their parts in their own way, with their own energy, getting to a point where Omar thinks they are ready to record (and even then, taking as few takes as possible in order to get the most "genuine feeling" for the piece).

Recording duties lasted for ten months, being done between touring. Jon Theodore started as the main focus of attention building upon Omar's guitar demos, being very methodical with how things were structured, bringing some of the most complex and layered compositions to date (and definitely some of Jon's best drumming on his time with The Mars Volta), establishing the rhythm on a way that both of them felt as proper for the songs, then it was all followed by Juan's bass and Omar's polished guitar, Ikey's keyboards (who wasn't very happy with the new recording method that was being employed), and then the rest of arrangement and percussion with Marcel and the guests. None of the members, or any of the people involved, really knew how the entire final product would turn out to be, but it was all more a leap of faith than anything, trusting Omar as the director who used the takes he considered as adequate for the piece, and seeing the final product when this one was considered as "done. Cedric explained it in the best way possible:

" It's really being in a state of being willing to give up to the producer your scratch tracks, as opposed to really working on it and refining it. I think the state that I'm in is having to be on my toes, and being able to instantly do something. Sometimes it's three or four in the morning and I'm calling Omar and saying, "Get our engineering. Wake 'em up. I've got an idea!" He's the same way, so we were constantly on our toes. It's nerve-wracking sometimes. A little stressful."

But still, by trusting Omar's vision, some of the best performances of every member came to be, creating a long album that had a lot to dissect in the way it was presented, with different moods on every instrument, but still maintaining a coherence with as a band (it has even been cited as the record that some members are the most proud of). A lot of songs were reported as composed during these sessions, but six made it out as the polished final products. However, problems still happened this time regarding the elaboration of the physical packaging of the album. Since all the six songs made up for ninety minutes of music, it would have needed to be presented on two discs, something that the label wasn't able to afford with the band, so one of the songs was removed from the final product, leaving the final version of the record with five songs in total (but even then there were some minor problems with the final CD case, with some titles or sentences misprinted).

However, the song is still considered important by the band, so many fans accept it as the original opener for many different reasons. In any case, the six songs that came out from those recordings are some of the best experimental/progressive rock to come out in the 2000's, a polished concept that has a lot to unveil beneath all the details that it offered. Intense, complex, unpredictable, unique, and simply mesmerizing. Frances The Mute was truly an accomplishment in most aspects of the band, and the compositions that it presented are most certainly something worthy of admiration.

++Frances The Mute++

The original title of the album was supposed to be Sarcophagus, but since one of the songs (one that the band considered crucial in order to decipher the concept behind the story told on the record) was removed, they decided to tie it all together by naming the album with the title of the missing piece. However, this song was not discarded from their catalog at all. It was released twice officially in single form, it was still played on live shows (something that was not usual for their "B-Sides", so its attachment to the main release was certainly strong), and its lyrics being included on the official CD version. Both official releases of the song came out the same day as the vinyl release of the album, and they were both attached to a different version of The Widow (with it being released as the B-Side of The Widow's single). But one of these was released as a main single attached to the triple vinyl edition of the album, being more proof that these two were certainly related without any doubt (sharing part of the artwork already seen on the CD booklet, and coming with a sound manipulated live version of The Widow).

Frances The Mute is, in many ways, a microcosm of what the entire album would be. This time the long songs were separated in different segments, almost as if they were strict movements, each one of them having distinct feeling to them, but still holding on together on a great was as just one big song being dynamic with it's tone, and also presenting atmospheric soundscapes that took its time to build up tension or set up a certain mood before transitioning to the next song. The lyrics were tied together with the vocal performance as another instrument that was used to have coordination with the music, and the final product can definitely be considered one of their most polished songs to date. The movements that this song presents are three, and every one of them has something special to offer.

A. In Thirteen Seconds

Right away, one of the deal-breakers of the album is presented. Frances The Mute uses long interludes/transitions between tracks. People usually argument that if those long atmospheric soundscapes would have been removed, the album would have had enough space left for this song to be included. Truth is that, even with fan edits of this being a thing or simply presenting an abridged version of the song, removing all this space, the result isn't quite the same. It feels much more rushed, much more sudden, with not a lot of balance between the quiet moments and the explosions of sound, something that didn't fall within their vision. One complaint about their last album was that it had little space to breathe, few calm moments to balance out all the intensity that was going on, and in many ways that seemed to be improved with this release, with these segments serving a lot of purposes for the entire experience. First of all, and as it was mentioned, they brought balance to the album, presenting these calm bridges that connected every song, setting up the tone or building up tension before the next long song came to play. Second of all, they helped to keep the flow of the album as something constant and without breaks (even on the vinyl releases, where these interludes where looped at the end and brought back at the beginning of the next side), also helping out with the setting of this being a "concept album". It is definitely something that asks for the patient of the listener, and it is understandable if people don't think these fit within the narrative or flow of the album, but their inclusion is certainly a vital part of the experience.

A first taste of this type of interludes comes right at the beginning of this track. Four minutes of bell tolls that keep building up within what seems really simple at first. The looping sounds of these bells have their atmosphere added with the inclusion of many other different samples, and a little before the four minute mark, some sound manipulation is added to the mix (setting up something that would be seen at the end of the song as well as in the rest of interludes). It all has a haunting tone, that builds up longer than one would expect, and then when the listener thinks he gets accustomed to the tension that was achieved, it transitions into the main part of the song, almost like a sudden explosion. The drums and the guitar are the main focus, being the main elements that lead the track, with the simple bass-lines being calm with what is being presented. Cedric's vocals take a lot of influence from different places, but they have a powerful tone that does its best to go along and stand out with the music. The use of different pedals between layers of the same guitar, as well as different vocal layers, add a lot to the track, setting a dynamic rhythm that varies a lot within the main tone of the track. It all leads to a guitar solo that replaces the vocals in volume, to then suddenly end the first section.

B. Nineteen Sank, While Six Would Swim

Acoustic guitars take the spotlight, the mood is changed, but the haunting and tense tone is still present. The use of different layers interacting with each other is intensified, with the vocals following along, agonizing with the mellow tone that they display, with Ikey being introduced with some notes, while Juan's bass is present in the background. The interaction between the whispers, the different guitar chords, it all serves a purpose with the tone of the lyrics. The use of distorted vocals is introduced, something that would take a big role within the rest of the songs (and even then they would expand this with future albums). The electronic guitar is introduced once again, within that mellow tone, while the vocals seem to build up slowly to a minor climax, then dying down, but suddenly introducing the drums showing a section full of coordination between all the instruments, building up to a different volume in the acoustic guitar, getting the atmosphere more tense, and then switching to electric into the final segment.

C. Five Would Grow, And One Was Dead

Here the tone changes once again, with things still following that coordination between the instruments, with a much more intense performance overall, setting this as the final climax of the song, with all rising in tone and displaying their emotion. After this, another interlude is presented, using the acoustic chords used in Sarcophagi, another movement seen on other tracks, thus connecting itself musically and conceptually with the main album. The guitar is distorted, as if it was being emitted through a radio, while some sound manipulation seen briefly at the beginning can be heard, finishing the track with these soundscapes looping in the distance.

Frances The Mute is a track full of details despite how simple or ambitious it might seem at first, and it is certainly an improvement on what many of their previous songs tried to do. The production and mixing is much more polished, with a perfect harmony between the instrument who carry the song forward and the ones who are there to back them up with the rhythm, but when the time comes to present a climax, everything takes the same tone and it all comes together on a very intense and powerful way. If one is patient enough with what is being presented, there is a big payoff awaiting, specially with the atmospheric segments that seem to be something extra, but that set the tone and mood of the track without the need to taking a moment of silence, keeping a consistent and well structured flow. It all has a reason to be, and every element comes together into this style of lengthy tracks in order to provide more to the listener. Certainly a musical accomplishment that manages to be surprising while being varied with its tone and moods, while still keeping a coherence between the different segments. Immersive, intense, haunting, and certainly enjoyable.



It is difficult to determine the placement of the song within the original tracklist of the album, since the appearance of Sarcophagi as its final segment suits it to be either an opener or a closer (that is why it is commonly labeled as "track 0"). But the most accepted assumption between fans, and even with some hints from the band itself, is that this was meant to be the original opener of the album, connecting itself directly with Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus. A lot of attempts at reconstructing the album have taken place by different fans, but even if taken as an individual piece, this is one of the band's most complete tracks. However, the tracklist in the official release is different, but even lacking this piece it still is one masterful experience of an album. And most of that can be credited with the way it grabs the listener attention as soon as it begins. 

++Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus++

A. Sarcophagi

As an opener, this song starts off on a very simple and misleading way, with a beautiful acoustic guitar, introducing different layers in order to create a sort of build up along side Cedric's calm vocal melodies, lasting almost a minute, adding some minor distortion just to then take the listener off guard and explode with its intense and energetic melodies.

B. Umbilical Syllables

This is The Mars Volta's official card of presentation with this new album, a much more frantic and explosive sound that uses all the elements it has to its disposition in order to create a layered song that is impressive with its unusual song structure, its unusual time signatures, and its fantastic performances. The use of different backing vocals to add to Cedric's tone, while the coordination between the guitar, bass, drums, and keyboards take place. The time signature is difficult to decipher, but it all hold together incredibly well, offering a carefully crafted track that goes verse by verse building up momentum at first, with teases to the chorus, just to then get into that place on a sudden way, exploding with the vocals, calming things down with the guitar, and then move back to the initial loud tone. And after the second chorus, it all seems to go into a chaotic place, but it keeps going on a calculated manner, transitioning into a much calmer segment, serving as bridge to the third section of the track.

C. Facilis Descenus Averni

This is the segment that was played instead of the atmospheric middle section of Drunkship of Lanterns in the live shows of the band. A very calm and atmospheric segment at first, with the drums going along with the bassline and the simple guitar riffs, introducing a modulated guitar solo on top of it all, with the drums slowly picking up elements to add to a build up that keeps going, catching the listener of guard, not letting him now when this build up will pay off. With the cymbals the volume seems to increase slowly, with the guitar layering on top of itself, adding to this build up that just changes in volume with the vocals taking the spotlight. David Campbell's wonderful orchestral arrangements keep adding to this experience, and while it keeps adding elements, it helps to build up tension and expectation, with Cedric's bleeding vocals fleshing out the vocal notes on different layers, leading to an intense drum and guitar solo, frantic and very chaotic, but still falling within that coordination, just to then return to the main chorus of the song. The payoff is worth it, with the chorus being much more intense than before, culminating on Cedric's vocals screaming out in tone, and everything becoming a convoluted and organized chaos, with many things happening at the same time, but still giving place to the final section with the bassline.

D. Con Safo

Juan's bassline, having a lot in common with 70's rhythm bass such as the one seen in King Crimson's "The Sailor Tale", leads the way between all the fading instrumentals and the soundscapes that are being presented slowly. Recordings of the street outside of Omar's house are introduced, helping to set the conceptual and musical tone for the next track, calming things down with the use of electronic samples and sound manipulation. It calms the tone and changes it without the need of stopping the flow of the album, building up with the samples and the car noises, shifting from all the adrenaline into a different tone that still maintains the tension.

This track is nothing but incredible, and a wonderful opener to such an experience (having a lot of impact every time, specially in the first listens). All the elements that are presented are balanced in many ways, creating a coherent track that, even if it consists on four different sections, holds together on a very tight way. There are a lot of things to take from here, with different build ups that payoff in their own satisfying way. Energetic, intense, and highly complex (with its song structure and time signature being a thing that is still debated to this day among fans, with only the end part being confirmed to be in 5/4 by Alderete himself); but still something accessible and enjoyable, surprising the listener with all the organized chaos that it presents. Even the decision of adding the atmospheric interludes is something essential, calming things down before presenting the mellow tone of the second song of the album.

++The Widow++

Starting off with as an acoustic piece with different backing guitar tones being subtle in the distance, while Cedric mellow vocals build up slowly to an explosive chorus with all the instruments being introduced. Juan's bass stays after to keep rhythm, keeping the mellow tone but building up once again to a chorus that transitions into a different section, with Flea's trumpet melodies complementing Omar's guitar solo, but it all stays in the tone established at the beginning, only building up in intensity, with Ikey's keyboard in the background right at the end, just to then leave everything to fade right into the next atmospheric interlude. A sample distorted and manipulated in different ways for two minutes, setting a tense tone with all the loops and ambiance effects, to then give place to the third track on the album.

With just three minutes, the shortest song on the album is as intense and layered as the rest of the songs on the album. The most successful single of the band gives a taste of the complex that the band added to what seemed like simple ideas, using a lot of elements to turn a song into their own, with their own way of making a mellow acoustic track into something unpredictable and dynamic with how the instruments are used. A great and small taste of what the band was able to do, and certainly engaging on its final result.

++L'Via L'Viaquez++

After some percussion loops courtesy of Marcel and Lenny Castro, volume starts increasing, giving way to one of the two energetic and wonderful guitar solos from John Frusciante. The latin influences come into play with this track, having percussion, guitar, and drums emulating a salsa instrumental mixed with the psychedelia and experimentation of The Mars Volta, making it a unique style to them. Cedric's spanish vocals achieve a tone and emotion that is very different from what was seen before, with some misleading bridge where everything becomes more frantic just to lead to the next verse. Vocal layers in between what was already seen, leading to the second bridge, with the bass leading into the first ambiance section of the song. Here, the mood changes, and everything goes into a dreamy section where things tone down in volume and intensity, with an impressive work between Ikey and Larry Harlow (one of Omar's salsa heroes, brought to collaborate with the band for a couple of tracks), creating a slowed down version of a salsa groove, being very unique with Cedric's dream-like vocals.

A second guitar solo from Frusciante breaks this atmosphere, leading straight back into the intense instrumental seen at the beginning. This time, it is all shorter, with only one of the bridges being used in order to lead to the ambiance segment. Everything seems to go normal, but then Omar's frantic guitar comes in along side a distorted soundscape in the background, with Jon's irregular drumming serving as the backbone of this segment. The string arrangement takes a big segment here, with Cedric's soft vocals contrasting all of this, leading into a small, but still fascinating, drum solo leading to the final section of the song. The ambiance comes back ones again, with Cedric's vocals being manipulated in studio, distorted and delayed (something seen on the single, but present here, and something that would later be expanded by the band on future records, but having a haunting and watery effect here), serving as bridge to a piano solo by mister Harlow, with different elements coming in, like Omar's watery guitar on top of Marcel's calm percussion. The vocals get more and more modulated, getting a more watery feeling with the different field recordings of people talking being added, leaving these twisted vocals as the final piece of the track, ending everything on a sudden way, and leaving the atmosphere calm before the next track comes in.

L'Via L'Viaquez shows the band being proud of their roots, of their musical taste and identity, by using their influence on a much more explicit way, but still managing to shift the tone and composition into something of their own, making the concept of a highly energetic rock song with latin elements into something that is pulled off on a fantastic way. Catchy rhythms, impressive performances, and a conceptual consistency with the rest of the record. Truly an accomplishment.

++Miranda That Ghost Just Isn't Holy Anymore++

A. Vade Mecum

A calm atmospheric section, using the field recordings of coqui (small frogs native from Puerto Rico), as the main part of this, building up tension for four minutes, implementing Cedric's haunting background vocals and other distorted elements until transitioning into the main section of the track.

B. Pour Another Icepick

The main song was a songs structure somewhat reminiscent to one of Miles Davis's electric era songs. Omar's acoustic and electric guitars, with Flea's trumpet solos, all complementing the haunting atmosphere, before the mellow vocals come in, accompanied with the subtle and soft violin and chello arrangements. The bass resonates in the distance, while the watery guitar keeps leading the main focus to the vocals. With the chorus, all raises in volume, but the mellow tone returns, with the trumpet still appearing on the distance. After a while, the drums come in to build up momentum with the instruments, culminating on a loud and melancholic rendition of the chorus serving as the climax of this segment.

C. Pisacis (Phra-Men-Ma)

The instrumental section here is kicked off by the string arrangements leading into the manipulated guitar coordinating with the trumpet, leaving space for Flea to perform some small solos that increase in volume at the end. It all leads the way into some radio noise, very similar to the one seen at the end of the single.

D. Con Safo

That radio noise/distortion leads into the reprise of the Con Safo instrumental, with the guitar and bassline coming in to build up atmosphere (along side some strings that have an evident King Crimson's "Easy Money" arrangement influence), finishing off Miranda on a very different tone than how it started. 

Miranda is the longest break on the album. A song that aims to shift the tone completely from everything that was seen until that point. It still has the loud segments with the impressive musical compositions and the powerful vocals, but it is all very calm and mellow in tone. It is certainly a long calm before the storm, before the longest and most intense song on the album takes place. Showing off a lot of the band's influences at the time (in fact it being very reminiscent of a Morricone film track, someone that they were inspired by a lot, even using A Fistful of Dollars as the intro track to their shows). Every member has their own small part in Miranda, and while it certainly doesn't have that frantic energy, it does stand out as one incredible track thanks to the performances that it provides.

++Cassandra Gemini++

(This is the track that has had the most problems with every issue of the album. On the CD it was misprinted as "Cassandra Geminni", and separated into seven sections, despite the back of the album showing only five. The vinyl version was no big help either, splitting it into two parts in order for it to go along with the rest of the songs. The digital version showed the rest of the tracks with their respective segments into just one song, but Cassandra was split up into seven sections, with every one renamed and changed. In reality, this is one giant thirty two minute song, and its mostly accepted that it contains five movements, so that is the version that will be seen here)

A. Tarantism

The Con Safo build up misleads the listener once again, and the first section of Cassandra Gemini starts abruptly, exploding into a very intense segment lead by the potent vocals, the bombastic drums, the frantic and complex guitar, and the subtle bass, having small climaxes where Cedric's voice builds up in tone, repeating these three times, before finishing this frantic and intense introduction, leading the way into the second segment of the song.

B. Plant A Nail In The Navel Stream

Distorted vocals come in, presenting Adrian Terrazas's flute (after this he would become an official member of the band), coordinating with the rest of the instruments. The guitar riffs are more irregular now, but they still feel balanced within the track, being played until Terrazas's saxophone mark a transition into a bombastic chorus. This is repeated one more time, before this next chorus extends itself, implementing different guitar interactions, introducing the bridge into the third segment of the track.

C. Faminepulse

Omar's first intense guitar solo should be indicative enough of the things that are about to come: more than twenty minutes of instrumental bonanza. A display of everything that The Mars Volta were until that point, showcasing their ability to twist a song structure into something unique to them, being unpredictable, intense, varied in mood, but coherent as a complete song. This is the segment that people either love or hate, asking for a lot of patience on a non-stop demonstration of talent and chemistry coming from the band. It is also the part where the live feeling from the concerts of the band starts to show, even production wise. The first and last part of Cassandra Gemini were recorded at a studio in L.A, with the jam that is presented after Cedric's vocals fade out being extracted from a long jam session recorded live in Australia and manipulated in studio by Omar. Here, the production shifts in tone, being something that many people won't like, but still, it is something done out of artists vision, and the way that it is pulled off is certainly outstanding.

Up to this point, it is something that must be heard in order to be understood. To many, including the one who is writing this review, this is the peak of The Mars Volta in studio form. The sudden changes, the use of the many elements in order to bring a complete sound into play, with every member giving their all with their performance, it is certainly an impressive achievement coming from them. It doesn't feel as long as it is, only increasing on tension and intensity with each passing moment, with everyone having their respective moment to shine.

It may not be the thing that does it for many people, along side many of the other things used across the entire album, but coming from a band that only wanted to express themselves freely and without boundaries, not worrying about what the critics or the fans said, and just taking their sound into the direction they felt like it, it is without a doubt something incredible to witness, and I couldn't praise it more if I tried to. A statement of a personal attitude and an artistic view that is made possible thanks to all the members that decided to trust the "director" in order to take the best from then and put it into one of the most eternal and fascinating pieces of music to come out from the 2000's.

D. Multiple Spouse Wounds

And after that long section, the structure seen on the second segment is brought back, lead by the frantic saxophone of Terrazas, but all of it is performed with much more emotion and many more elements added. It all serves a new purpose, since its used on a different way with a new buildup thanks to the strings and the different layers added to the vocals and the guitar, feeling chaotic but still maintaining order, leading to the fifth and final segment of the track.

E. Sarcophagi

The acoustic guitar from the beginning of Cygnus is brought again. This time, the vocal performance is different, much more agitated, contrasting the opener with this closer, going full circle and marking the end of this long non-stop experience.

++

The music that The Mars Volta managed to craft with their second album was an evolution of their abilities, as well as a way to showcase their true artistic vision to the world. It wasn't meant to appeal to everyone, but it was them doing what they wanted, polishing the songs with time and reaching a point where they were pushed beyond their limits onstage and on studio. Omar's direction was the backbone, but everyone had an important role to fulfill, and they did it with some of the best performances given by all the members. It was not nonsense being played just for the sake of impressing people, since they elaborated these tracks in order to be played live as well, pulling them off on jaw-dropping ways (even the long Cassandra Gemini would be played on its entirety live, showing that there everything had been methodical and carefully crafted in order to achieve that particular feeling of "organized chaos"). Every element had a reason to exist, maintaining a coherence, a tone, a mood, and a flow that would be very different with any of these elements removed from the formula.

But this musical bonanza wasn't the only thing pushing the record forward. Between the performances there was the idea of this as the second concept album from the band, with the cryptic and surreal imagery telling a much more condensed and psychedelic story. These lyrics had been constructed to complement the tone and the direction of the music, as the final touch that perfected all the album. And within that deep story relied a completely different beast that belonged to a world of its own.

I Won't Forget Who I'm Looking For: The Concept

There is no doubt that one thing that characterized The Mars Volta were the surreal and cryptic lyricism that accompanied every song. This started to be a thing in the early days of At The Drive-In, and it would keep evolving from that point. But The Mars Volta was much more loose and psychedelic, while maintaining a structure that worked for the end product, having a lot of detail, symbolism, and meaning upon closer inspection. De-Loused marked the first attempt of Cedric expressing himself the way he wanted to, creating a narrative dedicated to his old friend, Julio Venegas, while building lyrics around the music that was composed for the album. However, in order for the story to be understood, one had to look at the dense and complex short tale that came with the vinyl something that not many people were aware of. But things were aiming for improvement, and considering Cedric's varied influences, it would all evolve into a much more condensed and straight forward narrative, this time inspired by a particular experience of his old friend Jeremy Michael Ward. Eventually, this would all culminate in Frances The Mute being the band's second concept album.

Just like the musical aspects, there was a big evolution and polish involved compared to their first studio effort. Following the path of De-Loused, the lyrics are more imagery based, but there is a big change. While the debut relied on the literary piece in order to provide a full narrative, the lyrics of Frances are able to stand on their very own. There is not a big focus on the literary meaning of whats being displayed, its more about the images that they represent, making it something much more condensed regarding the story but also coded and open to interpretation. In combination for the music, the tone and the mood is set, but the images flow loosely, making it like a surrealist movie with a lot of messages opened to interpretation being crammed in. In Cedric's own words: " Our music would probably be a really dark ocean, so you may not know where you are. It's not so literal. It's like a David Lynch movie".


The inspiration from this new concept came from a very particular place that had been in the works ever since the band was starting with their career. Omar, Cedric and Jeremy lived in Anikulapo by the time At The Drive-In disbanded, looking to start fresh with The Mars Volta. Since they were still far from being able to make a living out of their music, all of them were taking part-time jobs in order to cover their common expenses, as well as the drugs that they were consuming at the time. Jeremy was working on a car repossession company, as a repo-man, while still being dedicated to the classic sound manipulation and performance with the new El Paso project. One day he found a diary on the backseat of a car he was repossessing, but what caught his attention were the big similarities between him and what was written: the story of a man who seemed to be looking for his real origins.

Jeremy himself was adopted, he never got to meet his true parents or his biological roots, so his name and identity were forgotten and overwritten by those who took him behind their wing, so empathizing with the person who had written the diary was fairly instantly. However, the story told in the diary was incomplete, and most of the people, including the original owner, remained nameless. In order to sort of "complete the tale", Jeremy decided to name the original author, a twenty five year old prostitute drug dealer whose investigation had lead him to find out that he was born out of rape, as Vismund Cygnus. His mother, who Jeremy named Frances (the use of the name Frances, might be a reference to Frances Farmer, actress who opposed to the practices of film studios back in the 40's, but that ended up deteriorating her life due to alcohol, eventually spending time on many psychiatric hospitals, being subject of brutal therapies, but also subjected to tortures and sexual assaults), was a mute that raped by powerful men and murdered while giving birth, or at least that was the information that L'Via, his biological aunt, provided to him. He eventually gets contacted by Miranda, his supposed grandmother, giving him the rest of the details he needs in order to unveil the truth. Vismund then decides to disguise himself as a woman, taking the name Cassandra Gemini, in order to take revenge for the actions committed to his mother.

After Ward decided to conclude the story on a way he saw as fitting, it was just bringing it to life with all the unique style of the band. The ideas started to come up since the days of De-Loused, but the sudden death of Jeremy changed the foundation of all the members that formed the band. It was no longer just about continuing what Jeremy had started, but also holding a close friend inside their memory and their music. This loose story was the root for the lyrics of the project, something that would serve as inspiration and backbone of the tone that ended up being presented. But instead of looking at the album as an idea, they saw it as a character, a resurrected body based on the thoughts of a stranger seeking to find the truth. Cedric and Omar decided to keep the narrative that was already established and complement it with the soundscapes and compositions in order to somehow bring the scenes and characters to life.

The songs were the first thing to end up being polished, with the lyric writing having a very particular process this time around. A lot of it was written on the spot at a time where Omar and Cedric were living together. Omar had a collection of TVs that he would stack and put different movies, like The Magnificent Seven or some Kurasawa films, in order to seek inspiration. Cedric would listen to the music first and then try coming up with the lyrics implementing elements from the diary. Things weren't constructed right away, writing down gibberish at first and then fixing them to make them into coherent words and sentences (sometimes the gibberish was kept  due to Omar's consideration that those first impressions went better with the music). For Omar, the album served as some sort of journal, a search for their roots. The fact that they were always touring, moving from place to place and encountering different culture clash, feeling that there is no real beginning or end. For Cedric  Frances could be about finding the missing piece, trying to look for biological family as opposed to maybe realizing your family is whoever is around you at the time, creating a corpse that comes to life and becomes its own thing, a gigantic open-ended question, as opposed to a solid meaning or concept. The result was very loose and expressive, looking more to invite people to come up with their own interpretations on this big narrative, considering that the ideal way to present the project.

Besides the musical influences, their main inspirations came from cinema, from directors such as Jodorowsky, Luis Buñuel and David Lynch, with their imagery and aesthetic inspired by the surrealism of those films. The end result was disorienting, full of details, open to interpretation; looking to create something that shakes things by the very foundation, leaving those who decide to check that work of art with something to remember. But that blend of cinema and music got extended even further, with the band not considering the interludes/in-between parts of the songs as such (as some minor filler that didn't get any sort of significance in the final album). To them it was all one long project with no sort of mindless pauses, having that ambiance as a way to suggest that there are things still happening while there is a build up for a major scene/song to happen. That blend of film with their music and lyrics resulted on a big focus on imagery lead by the sounds that were displayed, creating a very unique "movie for the ears". They wanted the "movie" to come out as a sort of black and white noir film, but it ended up becoming colorful as time moved on, and it was all sealed with Storm Thorgerson's colorful, mysterious, and haunting artwork (a man on a car with his face covered, as if he had no awareness of the direction he was heading to). The story that Jeremy found in the diary is completed and expanded in the album, with some impressive results at conceptualizing it, and being dedicated to their beloved friend and bandmember. As explained before, six songs were written, and even though only five made it to the final cut, the self titled song held coherence and consistency with the rest of the tracks, musically and lyrically, as the opener of the entire experience.

The final product was a story that blended incredibly well with the music that was being presented, with an evolving plot-line that was able to stand on its own as a complete narrative with a very dark and surrealist tone, full of open details. The tale of Vismund Cygnus, the man who lived a questionable finding out what he believes is the truth and seeking revenge by his own hand against those who hurt his biological family.

//What comes up next is a lyrical analysis in order to present what can be understood from the story, it is preferable if people decide to interpret the plot-line in their own way, but what comes here is what I consider the most consistent and understandable line of actions. Sentences or parts of the lyric explanation will be marked by numbers in order to be linked with the lyrics that are being analyzed//

++Frances The Mute: The Mother++

A. In Thirteen Seconds

The build up of the beginning is lead by bells, almost resembling those of a church, establishing the veil of haunting tension and mystery of things to come. The perspective of Frances is introduced, assumed to be dead, despite the fact that she was aware of that faith, predicted to her by her own captors (1). Perhaps it was her own fault that things ended up the way they did, by falling in love and having an affair with those who would end up leading her to her death (2). Perhaps the love interest was a priest, but the guilt and remorse for those who were involved in the sin was unbearable (3), leading to Frances being stabbed with an icepick (4).

It's been thirteen seconds since you all last said (1)
I've become the apparition you predicted for my death (1)
You said that flirting brings you closer to the end (2)...
...And like a stain of bricks goes dancing by your head (3)
Plucked from an icebox, grafted on my skin (4)

Point of view changes to that of the living son of the woman who was murdered, Vismund Cygnus, who removes and covers his scars, signs of his birth as a failed abortion (1). He imagines his mother talking to him during her pregnancy, being comforted and told that those who raped her and stole her purity would never harm him (2).

My coat has hid the marks, mink hits the shovel fix (1)...
She said, "I'll never let them hurt you, I'll never let them in (2)
What you took from me is mine, and what is mine I'll never give" (2)

B. Nineteen Sank While Six Would Swim

(Title being a hint to the line "25 Wives in the lake tonight" seen on Faminepulse (Plant A Nail In The Navel Stream for the digital version), perhaps implying that there were more victims from these violations and murders)

The church would find out about the pregnancy of Frances, leading to her death, and the birth of Vismund Cygnus (1). The fetus was born out of a failed abortion, so his face was marked by scars of this incident (2). Frances's body was disposed of, to never be discovered by anyone (3). However, there was a witness to all of this, hidden inside a closet, looking at all of these events (4). Vismund reflects about his past, believing that those who killed his mother are the same as animals who kill for instinct (5). It was all settled, Cygnus was determined to take revenge for what was done to her mother (6). As for her mother, she was murdered in cold blood and on a cruel way, with someone coming into the church to find her unconscious after giving birth and then stabbing her, tying a rope around her legs and letting her body hand for seven days (7).

...Her ash, a serpent infancy (1)
And his eye patch pussed through a gape of sand (2)...
...And you'll never find her body now (3)
In a closet festered in secret air (4)...
...Mingle with the carnivores, you've something both in common now (5)...
...Swollen throat and karma debt (6)
Set foot inside a parlor, to find her drunken by receipts (7)
He held her by the ankles, gutted at the nave. Yes gutted and depraved (7)
He tied a rope around her legs. And let her hang for seven days (7)

C. Five Would Grow And One Was Dead

This part is the one that leaves people in most confusion, one that is interpreted in multiple ways. But considering what would come right after in the story, this can be interpreted as both the witness, later revealed as Frances's sister L'Via, leaving the scene in denial of everything that had happened, looking to forget it all (1-2), or as Cygnus, who survived the abortion performed by powerful people to his mother, but ended up crawling into a life full of crime and unethical behavior on a dangerous environment (1-2) (something vaguely comparable to the broken windows theory).

This never happened, but I saw you leave (1-2)
And crawl into a bed of broken windows (1-2)

The final section of the song, however, used the chords of Sarcophagi , but lacking vocals and being run through radio static, implying the passing of time before transitioning to the main story with Cygnus.

++Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus: The Bastard Son++

A. Sarcophagi

Cygnus, all grown up, laments that he has never been able to know his true roots, his origin of life (the "ocean floor"), is something covered in darkness that he is not yet able to see through (1). Cygnus lives in full of pain and sorrow, because all his life he had been trying to overcome the scars left behind by the uncertainty of his true origins to no success whatsoever (2).

The ocean floor is hidden from your viewing lens. A depth perception languished in the night (1)
All my life I've been sowing the wounds. But the seeds sprout a lachrymal cloud (2)

B. Umbilical Syllables

Ever since he was a child, suffering surrounded Cygnus. All the pain and sadness built up like a poison inside of him, wanting to get out from where he was in order to seek for answers (Niño prepárate, que vas a sufrir/salte veneno/salte de aquí/labios temblando/vas a sufrir). Cygnus is seen looking through corpses in order to get any clues about his birth. He is frustrated by this (1), due to the fact that the bodies were on a poor state due to the need of the mortician to get rid of the load of work he had(2). Looking through countless bodies, Cygnus is determined to find anything that aids him with his search (3)

My nails peel back (1)
When the taxidermist ruined, goose stepped the freckling impatience (2)
And all the brittle tombs, five hundred little Q's. I'm splitting hair to match the faces (3)

Eventually, Cygnus finds some clues, he was the product of a failed abortion (1), all leads by a lineage of people who were used to these sort of crimes (2). Despite finding out all of this, a lot of information is still missing, feeling as if fierce talons were trying to cover something by getting rid of him (3). But even then, Cygnus was given a second chance as life, reborn as a sort of depraved phoenix, and he was not letting that go to waste (4).

Now this trail don't lie. An abortion that survived (1)
A lineage of bastard mastacation (2)
And all the severed proof, and talons scratch my suite (3)
These are the feathers that replace them (4)

Knowing all this, Cygnus is determined to leave his life behind in order to find out the truth even if it takes all his life (1). He is now reborn from rage, with raging blood flowing through his body (2). He was lied to all his life by her adoptive mother, who he doesn't feel like trusting anymore, and he is now looking for the answers in order to discover the truth (3).

Come on now. All night, I'll hunt for you (1)
Sangre sonando. De rabia nací (2)...
Who do you trust? Will they feed us the womb? Chrome the fetal mirage (3)

As Cygnus learned more and more about his past, the obsession started to get rid of that second chance that was given to him, as if it was a poison corroding his freedom (1). The clues are not enough to figure out who his mother was, and he wasn't taken care of by any of his biological family, so finding any sort of leads was important in that regard (2).

I found the remnants of a crescent fang, it cleaned my wing down to the bone (1)
Umbilical syllables left to decode. There was no cradle I can taste it (2)

C. Facilis Descenus Averni

However, Cygnus was no innocent person either. His life, full of vice and addictions/"plagues", such as smoking,  as well as practicing questionable professions (1). Still, all the hints to his past that he managed to obtained were covered in lies, so those addictions came well in order to avoid reality with the more information that he stumbled upon (2).

Bring me this plague...those nicotine stains on his every word (1)
My scavenger quilt will only hide the truth. Bring me, bring me this plague (2)

Vismund is waiting patiently in order to find out more about the truth, hoping that knowing the names of his family members will allow him to connect them in order to discover what happened (1). He still suspects people to be covering what happened to his mother,  and he suspects his mother to have been drowned in the river. But even then, with all the uncertainty, he knows one thing: his conception was violent, and her mother was murdered as soon as he was born (2).

I count the days to find what was left behind (1)
Only these names I clutch will lead me to my home (1)...
...Mothers and feathers start to drown the living proof (2)
I can't remember these lakes of blood, Wrapped in a blanket there sweats a cut (2)

The soundscapes presented after the song ends present street sounds, perhaps implying that Cygnus has started to move in search for answers. Cars, kids playing and running away from something, even if it was just sounds from Omar's street, it serves as a nice way of putting Cygnus's journey into motion.

++The Widow: The Observer++

The song dedicated to Jeremy Michael Ward, as it was established in many concerts. The perspective changes once again, now to that of The Widow, a woman who has been looking at Cygnus's actions from afar and is aware of how wrong and sinful they are. She describes Cygnus as someone who has problems speaking because of the condition of his lungs due to smoking, but he also may be addicted to other drugs (1). But despite being aware of all this, The Widow hears him, or remembers him, all the time, and his presence is something she can't seem to forget (maybe even being in love or having some sort of sexual affair with him) (2).

He's got fasting black lungs, made of clove splintered shards (1)
They're the kind that will talk, through a wheezing of coughs (1)
And I hear him every night, in every pore, and every time he just makes me warm (2)

Hints at Cygnus being a drug dealer are dropped, and even more, all those who buy from him become addicted to his product, even getting to the point of having injuries caused by the poison that they consume, maybe caused by injecting the substance directly to their skin (1). However, despite all these wounds in the customers, Cygnus seems to be perfectly aware of how addictive the drugs he sells are (2). But even then, he wanders the streets regularly, like a snake prepared to deliver his poison to anyone that is determined to get it, giving in to their sinful desires (3).

Look at how they flock to him, from an isle of open sores (1)
He knows that the taste is such, such to die for (2)
And I hear him every night, on every street, the scales that do slither deliver me from (3)

Later on in the story it is revealed that Cygnus is also a prostitute (and maybe the poison he sells can also be linked to that part of his life), and maybe that is where the affection from The Widow towards him comes from, not ashamed of anything in the world (1), feeling as if they will never be alone as long as Cygnus is by their side (even going so far as to choose death instead of another night without the warmth that is given to them, considering the fact that Cygnus left that part of his life behind in order to search for answers, implying that The Widow might have killed themselves as seeing that their lover/the thing they are addicted to, is gone) (2).

Freeze without an answer, free from all the same (1)
Then I'll hide, 'cause I'll never, never sleep alone (2)...
...Let me die, 'cause I'll never, never sleep alone (2)

The shortest song on the album, but also a very particular one. Being inspired by Cedric's mom's vision of the devil when she was young, looking at an ice cream vendor who she couldn't remember the face from, but also couldn't get the image of his chicken feet out of her head. With Zavala combining that with a dream of his own, where he encountered his father and he smeared black pudding on his face". It was also one of the two songs on the album to receive a music video. The band had stated that, with their intention of this resembling a film, a movie about the entire album could be made with no problem. The film influence leaked to the music videos coming from this album, but this one particularly, having a style reminiscent of surrealist cinema. That is why when it came for the artists themselves to direct the music videos, it became something important in order to further understand what was going on with the story, to get more pieces in order to interpret things on a more complete way (they even wanted to make a video for one of their long songs, but it wasn't too "commercial/friendly" for television at the time).  

The music video for The Widow was the one with the most production value added to it, having some of the most elaborated imagery up to that point. Things fall fairly within what could be seen with the lyrics, with Cygnus being a drug dealer that a lot of people in town are aware of, having a very elegant manner that is notices even by a Widow who retells his actions. Carrying the drug he sells into the city (on something resembling an ice cream cart) and making everyone addicted to it, seeming to be aware of how addictive it is. Targeting those who seem the most innocent or clueless of the situation, symbolized as children. Every new person that comes to judge him is marked by him and made into a new customer, even if they decide to do so from very afar. The town is twisted and full of odd actions from the townsfolk. The church is a place where the priest seems to be revered himself, with bones being brought to him as a sort of sacrifice (perhaps representing all the dead bodies that the church's actions caused), along side a snake, representing sinful actions on everything that happens across the video (and perhaps even representing the fact that people become addicted to the drug and give in to a snake, to their sins, giving away their connection to God). An addiction that makes people cry the same substance that they are consuming, since they are aware of the true coast of the drug. In the end, Cygnus himself walks alone, with no one being with him on his journey, but he himself is addicted to the drug, crying the same way as everyone who was addicted to the things they sold. 

++L'Via L'Viaquez: The Sister++

In the middle of his journey, Cygnus finds his biological aunt, L'Via (then finding out that Miranda is the name of his grandmother), who changed her last name to L'Viaquez (1) because she witnessed Frances getting killed by the priests and thinks that the church is looking for her (2). However, L'Via does have information to give to Cygnus, the main thing being that he was born the same night when her mother died (having the knowledge of a missing relative being a pain for both of them), and that the only thing that remained from her was the dress that Frances was wearing while being stabbed, with L'Via washing off the blood in order to keep it as a memory (3).

L'Via. Hija de Miranda. Tu apellido se cambió (1)
L'Via. Sin ojos me quieres dar una historia sin mi madre (2)
Solo tengo que decirte. El dolor de nohe dice. Solo se quedó el vestido, Le lavé la sangre (3)

Due to the fact that L'Via believes that the church is after her in order to kill her in order to eliminate the only witness of what happened to Frances (2), she is always on the run (1). Cygnus then, now knowing what happened to her mother, tells her that she can finally take a rest, to open her eyes and look at him, because her dreams of revenge will be fulfilled by Cygnus, promising that those who killed Frances will pay for their actions (3).

L'Via. No dejes de descansar. En la calle caminas ¿quién te va a perseguir? (1)
L'Via. Te quieren matar. Dientes de machete, cabeza de gallo (2)
L'Via, Durmiendo en paz. Abre los ojos, todo cambiará (3)
L'Via. Soñando de venganza. Y yo te lo juro, lo van a pagar (3)

Cygnus rests for a short period of time, but he has no time to waste while moving closer towards those who committed the crime (1). It has been twenty five years since he was born that faithful night (twenty five also representing what was seen on Frances The Mute), and all the bodies and injustice are still restless due to what had been done to them (2). L'Via seems to be restless as well, and even when she devoted herself to the church (drinking the blood, and eating the body of Christ), she can't help but to cry for what happened to her sister (3). Words and promised from the church crawled into L'Via's thoughts, as a form of comforting her, telling her that they wouldn't hurt her at all, but she still doesn't seem to trust them (4).

Sólo tengo una hora, y me duermo terminado (1)
Por veinticinco años pasaron, siguen los cuerpos aquí temblando (2)
Tomé la sangre, comí el cuerpo. Mis lagrimas quiebran el espejo (3)
When all the worms come crawling out your head. Telling you "Don't you be afraid " (4)

L'Via was blackmailed by the church and forced to stay quiet for fear of getting killed (1), but it is implied that Frances and L'Via were not the only victims of these people. It seems that more victims suffered the same faith as the sisters (either raped, killed, or silenced), and they all seem to look for justice (2). Vismund finds other cases, other bodies, uncovering a history of violence and extortion from the people who killed his mother (3). But even as he finds more and more destruction on his path, he has one thing clear on his thoughts, he won't forget the murderers who he is looking for (4).

Blackmailed, she fell off every mountain (1)
The ones they tightly wrapped in tape (2)
In her eraser sang the guilty, as it made the best mistakes (2)...
...Urgent plea of escape. A mouth to mouth on the chalkboard, written in fingernail distaste (2)
And with every body that I find, and with every claymore that they mine (3)
I won't forget who I'm looking for, oh mother help me I'm looking for (4)

This song was the second single, and the second and final track to receive a music video. This time around, production value was dropped, and what is used more here is an incredible amount of surreal imagery with different symbolism, so "decoding" all of this is very much subjective. Still, getting lead by what could be seen from the story, some things can be interpreted in certain ways.  At the very beginning of the video, representation of priests and religious objects are shown surrounding moving corpses/different bodies inside the ground, as well as people with chicken heads (considering that the chicken might also be a metaphor for sacrifice and that that particular imagery is described in the song itself). A silhouette of a kid running around can also be perceived, perhaps representing Cygnus himself. A lake of blood, with bodies floating with the current, symbolizing a history of violence and murders. The imagery of priests, different women, and dancing corpses, is stronger with every passing moment, but it is all tied to the same symbolism: Death. A figure crying on the top of skulls, displaying tragedy, and again implying that there are a lot of victims. Images of eyes are hidden all throughout the video, as if they were symbolizing someone witnessing something they were not supposed to. Definitely going along well with the lyrical content of the song.

++Miranda That Ghost Just Isn't Holy Anymore: The Grandmother++

A. Vade Mecum

The sounds of the coqui of Puerto Rico imply calm after a long journey, Cygnus has found another crucial piece in the puzzle: the whereabouts of grandmother Miranda. The title itself might have more weight to the lyrical content, implying that Miranda was once part of the church, but that she became an outcast, ignored, and treated as a dead person, just as if she were nothing but a meaningless ghost who lives haunted by the past.

B. Pour Another Icepick

Miranda would like to have another chance at looking at any of her daughters in order to talk to them one more time (1), even if it was about the tragic things that happened (but now that Cygnus is in front of her, she is finally prepared to have that difficult and painful conversation). However, just like L'Via, Miranda thinks that she is being spied on, so she couldn't find any way to contact her family due to fear to those who she thinks are after her (2). That group of dangerous people, the clergymen, is represented once again as Owls/Crows/Chickens, who constructed a specific environment meant to stop and tear Miranda, and maybe others that were trying to unveil the truth (these ones implied as failing in doing so), apart. However, Miranda was not stopped, and despite the things done too her, she kept fighting on in order to stay alive (3). The church's influence did a lot of things to tear Miranda's life, even killing her own blood, Frances, with an ice pick the night Cygnus was born (4).

I always wanted, to eat glass with you again (1)
But I never knew how, how to talk without walls dropping on the eave (2)
The nest they made couldn't break you. Along the fallen, scowled a fence of beaks (3)
But the temple is scathing, through your veins they were scaling (4)
Through an ice pick of abscess reckoning (4)

Miranda was aware of the existence of Cygnus, knowing that he and his mother were separated when he was born (1). However, even after such a long time since everything happened, the corpses are still noticeable to her, but even with the traces left behind by the church they would do anything to kill those who know in order to maintain the silence (2). Miranda knows about everything that the church has done, thus why she might have been a part of the church at one point, and she knows that her daughter wasn't the only victim from their actions. There were more women involved, killed by being drowned on a lake to cover the church's actions, but one day those actions would leave for all the piling blood to take their revenge upon them, and that is what Miranda truly wants (with that day being near, with Miranda telling Cygnus those last details he needed in order for him to fulfill his promise to L'Via) (3).

...Separating the mother from child (1)
She can bat a broken eyelid, raining maggots from its sty (2)
And with the traces that she leaves, she will skin you out alive (2)...
...And the dam she will break, make an ocean from this lake, as they siphon off all our blood (3)

The chorus is the most important part of the song, the one that explains why she seeks revenge but why she wasn't able to speak the truth. Miranda wanted everyone to know what happened, but no one listened, as the church had a lot of weight with all the citizens, who followed orders without hesitation. Miranda was ignored, or even silenced, thus why her need for justice grew stronger with the passing of time.

And when Miranda sang
Everyone turned away
Used to the noose they obey  

++Cassandra Gemini++

A. Tarantism

We are not aware of how long has passed since Cygnus visited Miranda, but one thing is certain, revenge is the thing that is driving him now. However, perspective seems to change, maybe to that of the so called Cassandra Gemini as an alter ego to Vismund, but things still follow a path set by a desire to provide justice by one's hand (so being sure if Cygnus is the one telling this side of the story is hard to decipher, since there seem to be multiple people involved from this point onward, being that this last track is the one that holds the most cryptic lyrics out of the bunch, but also being the one with some of the most important elements to the story. Still, this is a best attempt at maintaining everything on a coherent way with the rest of the story). Vismund has promised and decided to take revenge on the people who murdered his mother, but he realized he became just like them, just like those people who he hates. He would end up, or has ended up, considering that the tone and mood of the music resembles the intensity seen much later down the song, as nothing more than a killer.

I think I've become one of the others 

B. Plant a Nail in the Navel Stream

The perspective changes, and we are now presented to another narrator: a decrepit and perverted man who falls victim of a prostitute that gives him a lap dance and a sexual service. She was an "old decrepit prowl", but the man still decided to perform the sexual act in a very rough way, placing his hands on her torso, almost as if he was humping her. But after all that is done, she ends up damaging the man who had used her for her own pleasure. It is not specified if she was a killer, but perhaps she kept the bodies, or memories, of men as her own trophies (just like the men who wanted to be with her wanted to keep her as a sort of trophy to themselves). She has a certain elegance, a fancy way of acting, but her heels, the trail she leaves behind, scream of death (sarcophagus heels). It can only be assumed that the prostitute who commits these action is none other than Cassandra Gemini, and she might me the trans alter ego taken by Vismund Cygnus in order to take revenge on the men who murdered Frances, the mute silenced with death by those who committed sinful actions to her (the reason why the theory of why Cassandra is the same person as Vismund is lead by the fact that this point of view of perhaps a woman committing some murders is not heavily changed throughout the song, and knowing that Cygnus is the one seeking revenge, then associating the two into one identity makes sense for a lot of people).

There was a frail syrup dripping off his lap danced lapel
Punctuated by her decrepit prowl, she washed down the hatching gizzard
Soft as a mane of needles, his orifice icibles hemorrhaged by combing her torso to a pile
Perspired the trophy shelves made room for his collapse
She was a mink hand job in sarcophagus heels

Point of view changes again, with Vismund falling to his knees, as if he was praying, because everything was taken away from him in birth, seeking revenge the bible scriptures being  used as weapons to take advantage from innocent people (1). He is blinded by rage (2), not only because her mother had been killed, but also because her body had been tried to be hidden and disposed of in the Morgue (something he was suspecting when searching bodies at the beginning of his journey) (3). He has promised to kill everyone that participated in those acts (4). All those who survived where threatened or "comforted" by the church, but those words turn into dangerous worms causing panic and fear to those who try to escape, just like what happened with L'Via, unable to live a normal life due to those things, invading her sight, her words, and her thoughts. (5)

Bring me to my knees, read the sharpened lines (1)
All my arms bled me blind (2)
Faucet leaks in shadows, spilling from Morgue lancet caressed your fontanelle (3)
I've sworn to kill every last one (4)
Panic in the shakes of the wounded, panic in the worms (5)
Onto the floor, and out of your mouth and out of your eyelids (5)

But even then, knowing all of that and being aware of the fact that he wants to take revenge, something is still not clear, and his dark thoughts and actions seem to blind him even further, as if something was hiding from him.

No there's no light. 
In the darkest of your furthest reaches

It seems like someone is speaking to Vismund. He knows that Vismund left his life behind in order to pursue this dream of avenging his dead mother, being something that seems to drain him completely (1). Anyone would tell Cygnus that this search was meant to fail, that it would bring him nothing in reward (2). He is told that his mother was most likely a whore, who got herself involved in that problem by flirting with the one who would end up killing her, realizing how wrong her actions were too late, just as she was giving birth to Cygnus (3).

All your dreams splintered off, leech by leech on this catafalque (1)
Anyone will tell you, yes, anyone, chance had me setting a trip wire alarm (2)
Your mother flirted with disease, when she skinned that costume by its navel strings (3)

Cygnus finally confirms it and has no doubt about it: her mother was murdered when he was born, and he was tried to aborted. But knowing the truth doesn't free him from his pain, and he has decided to leave everything once again in pursue of vengeance, thoughtless violence, without feeling anything, not even remorse or compassion.

Shockless shackles free you, volt face cons
Abandon you again. I won't feel, not this time

C. Faminepulse

Cygnus knows the complete story now. He was born at night, while her mother was stabbed and killed by the clergymen who raped her, leaving him as nothing but a failed abortion (1). He sees that part religion as a flawed thing, giving people hope, but ultimately damaging them like they did with his family, and he would like the clergymen to taste the same pain (2).

Brick by brick the night eclipsed, pricked by cuticle thorns (1)
Dried the sleep of nursery slits, into this life I'm born (1)
Heaven't just a scab away. I'd like to see you after just one taste (2)

Cygnus survived that faithful night, but the clergymen did nothing concerning his life. In that regard, and wanting to take revenge, he wants them to know he is still alive, and he is going after them.

Let them see it has begin. The others I've become.

Her mother lived a sinful life, full of vice and questionable actions that ultimately lead to her demise, further seduced by sin itself, but Cygnus's life is no different, he is living in a very similar path as the one her mother walked on.

If you should see the dice. Charmed with its snaked choked eyes
You'll wear the widows weeds, because they're just your size

It was just about time before Cygnus got to this point, but even if it took long, he looks the nature of his birth as a deformity, with no fate besides the one he seemed to be fulfilling (1). He has everything prepared to complete his vengeance, and its more like an addiction than anything at that point (2)

...A limbless procreation, let the infant crawl deformed (1)...
...And now when the craving calls I'll scratch my itchy sheath (2)

L'Via found out about Frances's affair by the words and whispers of others, but she decided to keep quiet and cry in secret (1). The night of her sister's death, L'Via saw her being drowned on the river and being performed a failed abortion (2). And the followers of the priest who had raped and killed Frances obeyed without objection, destroying the evidence and the lives of those families who were related to the priest's affairs, letting everything burn with no remorse (3).

She fell for the whispers, sister flooded deaf tears (1)
That night tore a river, in her barren womb mirror (2)
And his multiple sons with their mandible tongues (3)
Set crucified fires to petrified homes (3)

The clergymen seemed to be aware of all these actions, but they were apathetic about it (1). They knew that Cygnus had survived and tried to kill him, unsuccessfully of course, as well as trying to get rid of all the evidence (2). They benefit from covering all this, letting their influence untouched and strong (3). They even seemed to be aware that L'Via had been a witness to all of this, but they either ignored her or decided to take care of it later (blackmailing her), but she didn't receive the same faith as her sister in the end (4). All the evidence was disposed of, and conceived from that murder was Cygnus, Vismund Cygnus (5).
(Another big interpretation of all this is that, due to the use of  "talon scratches" in Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus, these are real owls. They were waiting to eat Cygnus after, leaving some scars on him while L'Via fled the scene she had just witnessed, but ending up leaving him alive. It is still a valid interpretation, but doesn't follow too much the path of the man story)

And the owls they were watching, and the owls didn't care (1)
Then the owls came a'knocking, placenta in their stares (2)
They will feed on all the carnage, leftover from the flood (3)
And in the corner of their eyes, fled sister L'Via (4)
...Conceived from the stabbing was Vismund Cygnus (5)

There were more victims of these vile people, probably twenty five, something which was hinted early on, who fell victims of the church that seemed to be their salvation at first, but ended up giving in to temptation, perhaps even being stabbed in the same way as Frances, just to then be drowned on the lake, disposed of along side the evidence to keep the good image of the church intact.

25 wives in the lake tonight. Raw bark in the water of the marble shrine
25 snakes pour out your eyes. Yeah, the ice picks cumming on the marble shrine
25 snakes are drowning

Vismund seems to have finally got the revenge he wanted, or seems to be getting close to get it. He aims to inflict the same damage to all those who he saw as guilty, because he thinks that they made the victims suffer the same way Jesus did (1). Their death is getting near, and there is nothing they can do to avoid it (2). There seemed to be no refuge in the church for those who were wounded, full of murderers and rapists, but Vismund aims to make them feel as if their sins wouldn't be forgiven, and they wouldn't be shielded even inside their safe churches (3). Only their death awaits them, a punishment to eliminate all their breath as if it happened to be some sort of divine punishment (4). But still, with that rage and desire for vengeance, Vismund knows that her only chance at having a true family was buried with Frances, controlling her and Vismund's life even after death, and the crows would come to him once again, bringing nothing but pain (5). It seems that nothing but darkness awaits for him, and it feels as if something was still covering a bigger truth (6).

You can't bend your crooked arms, or fold your punctured proof (1)
The air is growing cold, and there's nothing you can do (2)
Soon there'll be no gauze, inside the confessional (3)
Only rows of crows, defrocking every breath (4)

One day you'll remember, behind the melting cones (5)
You've always had a family, in the burial of your home (5)

Night forevermore. And I peel back all of my skin. Peel it back let it all run (6)

D. Multiple Spouse Wounds

The promise of justice is repeated once again, as if it had been already fulfilled by Cygnus (I'd like to see you after just one taste), however, the darkness and uncertainty still remain in his life. His search, the truth, his lifelong journey to seek his origins, it all resulted on hollow bloodshed that still left him unsatisfied, living in the darkness. He got out of that long journey with nothing, his life, his motivation, it was all just a lie.

In the darkness of your furthest reaches (You ain't got nothing, your life was just a lie)

E. Sarcophagi

And just as if it were a dream, just as if everything that had happened so far: the people Vismund encountered, the revenge he took upon the priests, the life he left behind; it was as if everything was just a lie, a product of his imagination. We can't know for sure if everything was just an illusion caused by his drug addiction, or if all the things happened but Cygnus just can't seem to recall them at all, but one thing is for certain: it all came back full circle, to a state of never-ending uncertainty, with Cygnus lamenting not knowing, or perhaps wanting to forget, his past. No reward, no answers, nothing is certain. Crying in the night, with more wounds than ever before, uncertain of what is real or what is fiction, in complete and utter solitude. 

The ocean floor is hidden from your viewing lens. A depth perception languished in the night
All my life I've been sowing the wounds. But the seeds sprout a lachrymal cloud 

++

And that is how the story of Frances The Mute comes to an end. The way that Cedric and Omar were able to adapt Jeremy's anecdote with the unknown journal, turning it into a surreal and cryptic narrative that unveils crude and impressive imagery, is nothing short but respectable. It is not much just a story about revenge in cold by a bastard son seeking justice by his own hand, but something that touches addiction in many different forms. Vismund Cygnus being someone who is a drug dealer, aware of how addictive his product is, but also addicted to finding out the truth about his past. Both of these dominate his life, and once he starts unveiling his true origins, he becomes addicted to his anger and to take revenge upon those who killed his mother. The Widow is addicted to him, addicted to the warmth that Cygnus brings to her, killing herself when she finds out he will be gone from her life forever. L'Via and Miranda, both addicted to the past and to revenge as well, with those two being the things that ruled their lives with fear. The church itself, using religion as a way to fulfill their own sexual addictions. Cassandra, what can be interpreted as Cygnus alter ego, prostitutes for money, but is also addicted into taking the life out of the men who she sleeps with. It is that addiction that brings them nothing in the end, living an unfulfilled life, full of fear, pain, and panic; sinking deeper and deeper into the darkness.

It all comes full cycle on a fantastic narrative that does what all good concept albums should do: leave things open to interpretation, while complementing the music with the lyrics, transmitting different emotions while having a consistent set of characters and actions going on in a surreal world full of details. Frances The Mute was not only The Mars Volta's highest musical achievement, but it also showed their full potential in executing a concept in the best way possible. It was a balance between the incredible compositions, the haunting soundscapes, and the enigmatic lyrics. The story they provided was immersive, and they managed to pull it off on an excellent way. Jeremy's memory was honored, and the band moved on with their musical career steeping things up even more, expressing themselves as freely as they wanted to.

Truly, something fascinating to witness as a whole.

Frances The Mute

The Mars Volta's second album is, without shadow of a doubt, a complete masterpiece in the style that was unique to the band. Every element presented on their debut album is expanded and polished here, with the band applying all their influences and abilities into songs that were crafted following their own creative and personal vision. A lot of people who criticize then want more of the raw and frantic energy that At The Drive-In had, as if Omar and Cedric had an obligation to replicate that part of their lives, but that really wasn’t the case, and there really isn’t a point in comparing the two. The Mars Volta showed with this record that those days were behind, presenting a different energy, much more intense and complex on its arrangements, open to live improvisation and to a methodical formula for writing the music.

It was completely free from people outside the group who conditioned their vision, and Omar was able to record and produce the album in the way he saw fit, pushing all the members beyond their limits and bringing a long experience of an album that asks for the patience of the listener in order to deliver a big and rewarding payoff. There is a carefully crafted balance between the explosions of adrenaline and the mellow passages, with atmospheric interludes that keep this as a non-stopping experience that knows no breaks, but that knows how and why every element is used the way it is. If any of these elements were to be removed, the final product would be much different, since they help with both the music and the story being told through the lyrics that were themselves molded on top of the structure of the instrumental, while also being something that was dedicated once again to their beloved friend and ex-bandmate Jeremy Michael Ward. Presenting the story of Vismund Cygnus, a twenty five year old prostitute drug dealer whose investigation had lead him to find out that he was a failed abortion who was conceived out of rape, while her mother, Frances, was killed the same night of his conception. By contacting his aunt, L'Via, and his grandmother, Miranda, he gets enough information about those who took his mother's life, swearing to avenge his mother, disguising himself as a woman, taking the name of Cassandra, in order to fulfill his wishes for revenge. The lyrics adapt to the instrumental arrangements, being the main focus of the album, and they become both another instrument (due to Cedric's simply incredible and unprecedented vocal performance) as well as a world of its own, making up for one of the best concept albums to ever be crafted in music.

The music itself is simply a unique universe, being the perfect balance between all the influences that The Mars Volta had since their early days. From the heavy psychedelia and guitar precision from bands like Mahavishnu Orchestra or Pink Floyd, to the personality in how everything is presented ending up in creating a musical world unique to the artist, inspired by acts like Magma or CAN, the technical and theatrical elements on the music, coming from Genesis and King Crimson, to embracing their original roots with their prominent latin influences (with even Omar's childhood hero Larry Harlow participating on the record), to even adapting their heavy jazz fusion influences, mostly notably coming from Miles Davis' electric era, on both the way the music was recorded and how new elements were implemented into the music. It all results on tracks that simply have all their pieces fitting together. From the calm and misleading opening of Cygnus, leading into a frantic and powerful song, the bittersweet emotion conveyed on an energetic way during The Widow, the latin roots being appropriated and transformed into the lively and erratic L'Via L'Viaquez, the bleeding and beautiful melancholy of Miranda, and the colossal and continuous instrumental climax of the monster that is Cassandra Gemini (and even the self-titled single, following along with the spirit of the album, having been removed due to the lack of space on the final packaging, but still being maintained as a vital element to get the complete experience). 

Frances The Mute presents itself as one of the most forward thinking albums that can't really be compared to anything else, but that just takes from many places in order to create a layered, complex, and immersive experience. It is the final statement that an artist dedicated to his creative goals, artistic visions, and with an evident love for his music can manage to create. Not only is it a behemoth of an experience that has a monumental thirty two minute pinnacle serving as the climax for an album that already started showcasing everything that it could achieve, fleshing out that potential from beginning to end, but it was also the culmination of everything The Mars Volta had been working on until that point. All the influences are blended into one dynamic, engaging, non-stop flow of punches to the brain, the ear, and the soul of the one who is listening. An experience that seems to violently shift between atmospheres and tones at random points, just for the listener to eventually figure out that it is all intentional. It all has a reason to be, every element has a reason to exist, and it even goes to the length of reusing motives and ideas in order to go full circle, to enclose this as a world of its own, to show an otherworldly conclusion to what was an already otherworldly experience, simply majestic in every possible aspect.

It is not everyone’s cup of tea, but it doesn’t have to be. It is not a record for everyone, since the long songs and the long interludes ask a lot of patience from the listener, which can see them as mindless filler or "instrumental/prog wankery". The layers of detail, of a non stop flow that has an unconventional way of structuring itself, offer something that will not be of the liking of a lot of people, but it does have a lot to offer to those who know what they are in for. They were not aiming to create a masterpiece or something that pleased audiences, it simply was their own and unique way to express themselves, using those long songs and those long interludes as a way to craft a record in the way they wanted to, with no creative limitations. It is completely understandable if people see this as flawed or pretentious, but for many this is a band on their absolute peak. Despite everything looking like a mess for some, it is simply an organized chaos, and their live shows are more than enough proof of that, with the band replicating all these elements, and even fleshing them out to a further extent, with long concerts that were free and loose in experience, but that were lead with the passion and technicality that were some of the main components to the unique spirit of the band. A band that gave their all in any setting, showing a strong chemistry and ability with their music.

The Mars Volta were a group that didn't fall into any sort of name or label, being something quite unique that was lead by the vision of artists distinguishing themselves from what they considered as the norm in music. With the use of their many and varied influences, they created a sound that knew no age, that was timeless in how creative and isolated it was, free in spirit, and layered in execution. They invited anyone to witness the move like soundscapes that they had created. Frances The Mute was not only a staple on their career, but on the world of progressive rock and music in general, being a one of a kind project that will never meet a match in any aspect, simply because getting to this level of personality and intention in creating an album is incredibly hard. It cemented them even further as a band that had a lot to offer with their particular vision, being something that will never be replicated in history. It is a unique experience that has to be heard in order to be fully understood. 

A complete and absolute masterpiece.

O-U - Buddy, Ekoda, Tokyo, Japan, 14-11-2003 / Bootleg Download

  Among the many branches of the rich Japanese progressive/fusion/avant/experimental rock scene, there are a lot of groups and records that ...